Bell Jacqui, Dale Bonnie, Kameron Caitlin, Havill Michelle
Legal Policy Advisor, Cancer Council Victoria.
Public Health Coordinator, Cancer Council Queensland.
J Law Med. 2018 Feb;25(2):465-488.
There is an immediate need to reform Australian State and Territory strata laws to minimise exposure to second-hand smoke (SHS) in multiunit housing (MUH), particularly in light of the trend towards higher density living. SHS is a cause of lung cancer and other health problems in nonsmokers and no safe level of exposure has been established. Despite being a common cause of dispute in MUH, currently no strata regime in any State or Territory includes a model by-law that specifically addresses smoking, as is the case with other contentious issues like pets. Smoking disputes can currently be dealt with under general strata provisions on nuisances or hazards, but the case law in this area demonstrates that these provisions can be ineffective in dealing with the serious health issue posed by SHS. With enough votes, owners' corporations can introduce a smoking by-law. However, without legal advice it may be difficult for owners' corporations to develop a by-law they can be confident falls within their by-law making powers. With several jurisdictions currently reviewing their strata laws, there is a valuable opportunity to sensibly reform the law in the interests of public health. In this article, we survey the legal landscape and consider options for a model by-law on smoking.
迫切需要改革澳大利亚各州和领地的分层法,以尽量减少多单元住房(MUH)中二手烟(SHS)的暴露,特别是考虑到居住密度增加的趋势。二手烟是非吸烟者患肺癌和其他健康问题的一个原因,而且尚未确定安全的暴露水平。尽管二手烟是多单元住房中常见的争议原因,但目前任何州或领地的分层制度都没有像宠物等其他有争议问题那样,包含专门针对吸烟的示范附例。目前,吸烟纠纷可以根据关于滋扰或危险的一般分层规定来处理,但这方面的判例法表明,这些规定在处理二手烟带来的严重健康问题时可能无效。如果获得足够的投票,业主团体可以制定一项吸烟附例。然而,如果没有法律建议,业主团体可能很难制定出一项他们确信在其附例制定权范围内的附例。鉴于目前有几个司法管辖区正在审查其分层法,有一个宝贵的机会为了公众健康利益明智地改革法律。在本文中,我们审视了法律现状,并考虑了关于吸烟示范附例的选项。