Guzzo Matthew M, Van Leeuwen Travis E, Hollins Jack, Koeck Barbara, Newton Matthew, Webber Dale M, Smith Frank I, Bailey David M, Killen Shaun S
Department of Biological Sciences University of Manitoba Winnipeg Manitoba Canada.
Institute of Biodiversity Animal Health & Comparative Medicine University of Glasgow Glasgow UK.
Methods Ecol Evol. 2018 Jun;9(6):1478-1488. doi: 10.1111/2041-210X.12993. Epub 2018 Mar 24.
Acoustic telemetry is an important tool for studying the behaviour of aquatic organisms in the wild.VEMCO high residence (HR) tags and receivers are a recent introduction in the field of acoustic telemetry and can be paired with existing algorithms (e.g. VEMCO positioning system [VPS]) to obtain high-resolution two-dimensional positioning data.Here, we present results of the first documented field test of a VPS composed of HR receivers (hereafter, HR-VPS). We performed a series of stationary and moving trials with HR tags (mean HR transmission period = 1.5 s) to evaluate the precision, accuracy and temporal capabilities of this positioning technology. In addition, we present a sample of data obtained for five European perch implanted with HR tags (mean HR transmission period = 4 s) to illustrate how this technology can estimate the fine-scale behaviour of aquatic animals.Accuracy and precision estimates (median [5th-95th percentile]) of HR-VPS positions for all stationary trials were 5.6 m (4.2-10.8 m) and 0.1 m (0.02-0.07 m), respectively, and depended on the location of tags within the receiver array. In moving tests, tracks generated by HR-VPS closely mimicked those produced by a handheld GPS held over the tag, but these differed in location by an average of ≈9 m.We found that estimates of animal speed and distance travelled for perch declined when positional data for acoustically tagged perch were thinned to mimic longer transmission periods. These data also revealed a trade-off between capturing real nonlinear animal movements and the inclusion of positioning error.Our results suggested that HR-VPS can provide more representative estimates of movement metrics and offer an advancement for studying fine-scale movements of aquatic organisms, but high-precision survey techniques may be needed to test these systems.
声学遥测是研究野生水生生物行为的重要工具。VEMCO高驻留(HR)标签和接收器是声学遥测领域的最新产品,可与现有算法(如VEMCO定位系统 [VPS])配合使用,以获取高分辨率二维定位数据。在此,我们展示了由HR接收器组成的VPS(以下简称HR-VPS)首次有记录的现场测试结果。我们使用HR标签(平均HR传输周期 = 1.5秒)进行了一系列静态和动态试验,以评估这种定位技术的精度、准确性和时间性能。此外,我们展示了为五条植入HR标签(平均HR传输周期 = 4秒)的欧洲鲈鱼获取的数据样本,以说明该技术如何估计水生动物的精细行为。所有静态试验中HR-VPS位置的准确性和精度估计(中位数[第5-95百分位数])分别为5.6米(4.2-10.8米)和0.1米(0.02-0.07米),并取决于标签在接收器阵列中的位置。在动态测试中,HR-VPS生成的轨迹与标签上方手持GPS生成的轨迹非常相似,但这些轨迹在位置上平均相差约9米。我们发现,当对声学标记鲈鱼的位置数据进行稀疏处理以模拟更长的传输周期时,鲈鱼的速度和行进距离估计值会下降。这些数据还揭示了在捕捉真实的非线性动物运动与纳入定位误差之间的权衡。我们的结果表明,HR-VPS可以提供更具代表性的运动指标估计,并为研究水生生物的精细运动提供进展,但可能需要高精度的测量技术来测试这些系统。