Abrah Prince Boamah
1 University of Ghana, Accra, Ghana.
Int J Offender Ther Comp Criminol. 2019 Feb;63(2):179-197. doi: 10.1177/0306624X18787303. Epub 2018 Jul 17.
Labeling theory contends that an acquisition of a criminal status can be very problematic for offenders navigating into adulthood. This article examines this assertion with the life story of 23 juvenile delinquents. The objective of the study was to gain insight into how the negative reactions of friends, families, and society worked to change and reinforced their offending behavior. The qualitative data which resulted from the use of semi-structured interview guide revealed that self-motivation of offenders to move into "new" neighborhoods and the lack of labeling triggered a turning point among those who desisted than the persistent offenders. The theoretical implication of this finding is that labeling per se may not necessarily explain persistence in crime considering how those who desisted from crime maneuvered their labeling status in the face of discrimination. In formulating a desistance theory of crime and delinquency, criminologists need to revise and evaluate traditional labeling theory with life histories of offenders in the desistance process. This shift in paradigm will inform the coping mechanism of more offenders, as well as the appropriate techniques and strategies to reduce recidivism. Strengthening prison aftercare programs, provision of institutional and social support, and the integration of residential change into post offenders' treatment therapy will be in the right direction for policy makers.
标签理论认为,获得犯罪身份对步入成年期的罪犯来说可能非常成问题。本文通过23名少年犯的人生故事来审视这一论断。该研究的目的是深入了解朋友、家人和社会的负面反应如何改变并强化了他们的犯罪行为。使用半结构化访谈指南所产生的定性数据显示,与那些惯犯相比,那些停止犯罪的人之所以出现转折点,是因为他们有自我激励去搬到“新”社区,且缺乏标签化。这一发现的理论意义在于,考虑到那些停止犯罪的人在面对歧视时如何应对他们的标签化身份,标签化本身不一定能解释犯罪的持续性。在制定犯罪和青少年犯罪的停止理论时,犯罪学家需要根据停止犯罪过程中罪犯的人生经历来修订和评估传统的标签理论。这种范式的转变将为更多罪犯的应对机制提供信息,以及为减少累犯的适当技术和策略提供信息。加强监狱后续照管项目、提供机构和社会支持,以及将居住环境的改变纳入罪犯出狱后的治疗中,将是政策制定者的正确方向。