Agarwal Nitin, White Michael D, Hamilton D Kojo
J Neurosurg Spine. 2018 Oct;29(4):442-447. doi: 10.3171/2018.3.SPINE171370. Epub 2018 Jul 20.
Currently, there is a lack of research assessing residents' operative experience and caseload variability. The current study utilizes data from the Accreditation Council for Graduate Medical Education (ACGME) case log system to analyze national trends in neurosurgical residents' exposure to adult spinal procedures.
Prospectively populated ACGME resident case logs from 2013 to 2017 were retrospectively reviewed. The reported number of spinal procedures was compared to the ACGME minimum requirements for each surgical category pertaining to adult spine surgery. A linear regression analysis was conducted to identify changes in operative caseload by residents graduating during the study period, as well as a one-sample t-test using IBM SPSS software to compare the mean number of procedures in each surgical category to the ACGME required minimums.
A mean of 427.42 total spinal procedures were performed throughout residency training for each of the 877 residents graduating between 2013 and 2017. The mean number of procedures completed by graduating residents increased by 19.96 (r = 0.95) cases per year. The number of cases in every procedural subspecialty, besides peripheral nerve operations, significantly increased during this time. The two procedural categories with the largest changes were anterior and posterior cervical approaches for decompression/stabilization, which increased by 8.78% per year (r = 0.95) and 9.04% per year (r = 0.95), respectively. There was also a trend of increasing cases logged for lead resident surgeons and a decline in cases logged for senior resident surgeons. Residents' mean caseloads during residency were found to be vastly greater than the ACGME required minimums: residents performed at least twice as many procedures as the required minimums in every surgical category.
Graduating neurosurgical residents reported increasing case volumes for adult spinal cases during this 5-year interval. An increase in logged cases for lead resident surgeons as opposed to senior resident surgeons indicates that residents were logging more cases in which they had a more critical role in the procedure. Moreover, the average resident was noted to perform more than twice the number of procedures required by the ACGME in every surgical category, indicating that neurosurgical residents are getting greater exposure to spine surgery than expected. Given the known correlation between case volume and improved surgical outcomes, this data demonstrates each graduating neurosurgical residency class experiences an augmented training in spine surgery.
目前,缺乏对住院医师手术经验和病例数量变异性的研究。本研究利用毕业后医学教育认证委员会(ACGME)病例记录系统的数据,分析神经外科住院医师进行成人脊柱手术的全国趋势。
对2013年至2017年前瞻性录入的ACGME住院医师病例记录进行回顾性审查。将报告的脊柱手术数量与ACGME对成人脊柱手术各手术类别的最低要求进行比较。进行线性回归分析,以确定研究期间毕业的住院医师手术病例数量的变化,以及使用IBM SPSS软件进行单样本t检验,以比较每个手术类别的平均手术数量与ACGME要求的最低数量。
2013年至2017年毕业的877名住院医师中,每人在整个住院医师培训期间平均进行了427.42例脊柱手术。毕业住院医师完成的平均手术数量每年增加19.96例(r = 0.95)。在此期间,除周围神经手术外,每个手术亚专业的病例数量均显著增加。变化最大的两个手术类别是颈椎前路和后路减压/稳定手术,每年分别增加8.78%(r = 0.95)和9.04%(r = 0.95)。总住院医师主刀的病例数量也有增加趋势,而高年资住院医师主刀的病例数量呈下降趋势。发现住院医师培训期间的平均病例数量远高于ACGME要求的最低数量:住院医师在每个手术类别中进行的手术数量至少是要求最低数量的两倍。
在这5年期间,毕业的神经外科住院医师报告成人脊柱病例数量增加。总住院医师主刀的病例记录增加,而高年资住院医师主刀的病例记录减少,这表明住院医师记录的病例中,他们在手术中发挥更关键作用的病例更多。此外,注意到平均住院医师在每个手术类别中进行的手术数量超过ACGME要求数量的两倍,这表明神经外科住院医师接受脊柱手术培训的机会比预期更多。鉴于已知病例数量与改善手术结果之间的相关性,这些数据表明每个毕业的神经外科住院医师班级在脊柱手术方面都接受了强化培训。