Suppr超能文献

传统伊朗医学中的科学与伪科学。

Science and Pseudoscience in Traditional Iranian Medicine.

机构信息

Director, James F. Drane Bioethics Institute, Edinboro University of Pennsylvania, Edinboro, PA, USA.

Associate Professor, Medical Ethics and History of Medicine Research Center, Tehran University of Medical Sciences, Tehran, Iran.

出版信息

Arch Iran Med. 2018 Jul 1;21(7):315-323.

Abstract

The recent efforts for revitalizing traditional Iranian medicine (TIM) have shaped two main streams: The quackery traditional iranian medicine (QTIM) and the academic traditional iranian medicine (ATIM). The QTIM encompasses a wide range of practitioners with various backgrounds who work outside the academic arena and mostly address the public. These practitioners have no solid bases or limited boundaries for their claims. Instead, they rely on making misleading references to the Holy Islamic Scriptures, inducing false hope, claiming miraculous results, appealing to the conspiracy theories, and taking advantage of the public resentment toward some groups of unprofessional healthcare providers. The theories and practices of ATIM, however, can be categorized into two major categories: First, valid and scientific TIM that is aimed to conduct well-designed clinical trials and thereby, supply the evidence-based medicine with new treatments originated in or inspired by TIM. Second, a pseudoscientific part of the current TIM that is based on some obsolete medical theories, especially the medieval humoral medicine, and erroneous accounts of human anatomy, physiology, and physiopathology, mostly adopted from the ancient and medieval medical scripts. TIM has recently established some clinical centers for practicing humoral medicine that is partly pseudoscientific and involves significant risks. This paper suggests that the public health sector has a duty to act against the promulgation of medical superstitions by QTIM and the pseudoscientific medical practices of ATIM, and at the same time, support and promote the valid and potentially beneficial research pursued by ATIM aimed to explore the rich recourses of TIM and thereby enrich the evidence-based medicine.

摘要

最近振兴伊朗传统医学(TIM)的努力形成了两个主要流派:庸医伊朗传统医学(QTIM)和学术伊朗传统医学(ATIM)。QTIM 涵盖了各种背景的广泛从业者,他们在学术领域之外工作,主要面向公众。这些从业者的主张没有坚实的基础或有限的界限。相反,他们依靠对圣古兰经做出误导性的引用、制造虚假希望、声称神奇的效果、诉诸阴谋论,并利用公众对一些不专业医疗保健提供者的怨恨。然而,ATIM 的理论和实践可以分为两大类:第一,有效的和科学的 TIM,旨在进行精心设计的临床试验,从而为循证医学提供源自 TIM 或受其启发的新治疗方法。第二,是当前 TIM 中的伪科学部分,它基于一些过时的医学理论,特别是中世纪的体液医学,以及对人体解剖学、生理学和病理生理学的错误描述,主要来自古代和中世纪的医学著作。TIM 最近建立了一些实践体液医学的临床中心,其中部分是伪科学的,并涉及重大风险。本文认为,公共卫生部门有责任反对 QTIM 传播医学迷信和 ATIM 的伪科学医疗实践,同时支持和促进 ATIM 进行有效的、潜在有益的研究,以探索 TIM 的丰富资源,从而丰富循证医学。

文献AI研究员

20分钟写一篇综述,助力文献阅读效率提升50倍。

立即体验

用中文搜PubMed

大模型驱动的PubMed中文搜索引擎

马上搜索

文档翻译

学术文献翻译模型,支持多种主流文档格式。

立即体验