Guerrette Marie-Claude, Saint-Aubin Jean, Richard Mylène, Guérard Katherine
École de psychologie, Université de Moncton, Moncton, New Brunswick, Canada.
Département de psychologie, Université de Montréal, Montréal, Québec, Canada.
Mem Cognit. 2018 Nov;46(8):1389-1397. doi: 10.3758/s13421-018-0844-2.
When asked to recall verbatim a short list of items, performance is very limited. However, if the list of items is repeated across trials, recall performance improves. This phenomenon, known as the Hebb repetition effect (Hebb, 1961; Brain Mechanisms and Learning: A Symposium, pp. 37-51), is considered a laboratory analogue of language learning. In effect, learning a new word implies the maintenance of a series of smaller units, such as phonemes or syllables, in the correct order for a short amount of time before producing them. The sequence of smaller units is typically presented more than once. In the present study, we investigated the role of overt language production in language learning by manipulating recall direction. If the learning of a repeated list of items relies on overt language production processes, changing list production order by manipulating recall direction should impact the learning of the list. In Experiment 1, one list was repeated every third trial, and recall direction of the repeated list changed on the ninth repetition. In Experiment 1a, the repeated list changed from a forward to a backward order recall, where participants had to recall the items in reverse presentation order. In Experiment 1b, the repeated list changed from a backward to a forward order recall. Results showed a cost in recall performance for the repeated list when recall direction switched from forward to backward recall, whereas it was unaffected by the change from backward to forward recall. In Experiment 2, we increased the number of trials before introducing the change from a backward to a forward order recall. Results showed a decrement in recall performance for the repeated list following the change in recall direction, suggesting that language production processes play a role in the Hebb repetition effect.
当被要求逐字回忆一小串物品时,表现非常有限。然而,如果这串物品在多次试验中重复出现,回忆表现会有所提高。这种现象,即赫布重复效应(赫布,1961年;《脑机制与学习:研讨会》,第37 - 51页),被认为是语言学习的实验室模拟。实际上,学习一个新单词意味着在短时间内以正确顺序维持一系列较小的单元,如音素或音节,然后再产出这些单元。较小单元的序列通常会呈现不止一次。在本研究中,我们通过操纵回忆方向来探究外显语言产出在语言学习中的作用。如果对重复物品列表的学习依赖于外显语言产出过程,那么通过操纵回忆方向改变列表产出顺序应该会影响对该列表的学习。在实验1中,每第三次试验重复一个列表,并且在第九次重复时改变重复列表的回忆方向。在实验1a中,重复列表从正向回忆变为反向回忆,即参与者必须以相反的呈现顺序回忆这些物品。在实验1b中,重复列表从反向回忆变为正向回忆。结果表明,当回忆方向从正向回忆切换到反向回忆时,重复列表的回忆表现会受到影响,而从反向回忆变为正向回忆则对其没有影响。在实验2中,我们增加了在引入从反向回忆到正向回忆的变化之前的试验次数。结果表明,回忆方向改变后,重复列表的回忆表现有所下降,这表明语言产出过程在赫布重复效应中发挥了作用。