Satav Vikram, Sabale Vilas, Pramanik Prasun, Kanklia Sharad P, Mhaske Sunil
Department of Urology, Dr. D. Y. Patil Medical College, Pune, Maharashtra, India.
Urol Ann. 2018 Jul-Sep;10(3):258-262. doi: 10.4103/UA.UA_152_17.
To review our success in PCNL for managing large horse shoe kidney stones as primary treatment.
Between 2012 and 2016, a total of 23patients (24 renal units) underwent percutaneous renal surgery for stone dieses in horseshoe kidneys. Indications were HSK with stone more than 1 cm in size and failed ESWL.
Mean age was 35.60 ± 10.10 years out of which 18 were males and 5 females. One patient had stone in both kidneys. Mean stone size was 22.03 ± 10.33 mm. Access site was upper calyceal and subcostal in all patients. In 2 patients an extra middle calyceal puncture were used for total clearance (8.69%). Mean operation time was 67.22 ± 7.63 minutes. One patient with staghorn stone was converted to open surgery because of inaccessibility of the stone and complexity of the renal calyceal system. Post operatively, 2 renal units with residual stone more than 8mm were cleared with ESWL. Complete clearance was achieved in 21 renal units with PCNL (87.50%). There was no significant intra operative complication. Post operatively 2 patients developed fever which was treated conservatively(clavien grade I).
PCNL can be recommended as first line of management in the treatment of horseshoe kidneys with large stone burden considering its higher clearance rate and minimal complications.
回顾我们在经皮肾镜取石术(PCNL)治疗大型马蹄肾结石作为主要治疗方法方面的成功经验。
2012年至2016年间,共有23例患者(24个肾单位)因马蹄肾结石疾病接受了经皮肾手术。适应症为结石大小超过1厘米且体外冲击波碎石术(ESWL)失败的马蹄肾结石。
平均年龄为35.60±10.10岁,其中男性18例,女性5例。1例患者双侧肾脏有结石。平均结石大小为22.03±10.33毫米。所有患者的穿刺部位均为上盏和肋下。2例患者额外采用中盏穿刺以实现完全清除(8.69%)。平均手术时间为67.22±7.63分钟。1例鹿角形结石患者因结石难以触及且肾盏系统复杂而转为开放手术。术后,2个残留结石超过8毫米的肾单位通过ESWL清除。21个肾单位通过PCNL实现了完全清除(87.50%)。术中无明显并发症。术后2例患者出现发热,经保守治疗(Clavien I级)。
考虑到PCNL的清除率较高且并发症最少,可推荐其作为治疗结石负荷大的马蹄肾的一线治疗方法。