Krammer Sandy, Maercker Andreas, Grosse Holtforth Martin, Gamma Alex, Liebrenz Michael
Forensisch-Psychiatrischer Dienst, Institut für Rechtsmedizin, Universität Bern, Schweiz.
Psychologisches Institut, Universität Zürich, Schweiz.
Fortschr Neurol Psychiatr. 2019 Feb;87(2):112-120. doi: 10.1055/s-0044-101545. Epub 2018 Aug 13.
The eleventh version of the ICD, expected to be published in 2018, leads to changed criteria for post-traumatic stress disorder (PTSD) according to the online beta version. Such changes are likely to affect previously known features of PTSD, including the prevalence rate. Little is known about the prevalence of ICD-11 PTSD in imprisoned men. The present study examined this issue in this high-risk group for trauma disorders, as male prisoners are known to be more often affected by traumatic events compared to the general population.
In n = 49 men imprisoned in Switzerland, cross-sectional and standardized self-assessment procedures (ACE, Cidi list, IES-R) were used to record traumatic events and possible trauma symptoms. The frequency of ICD-11 PTSD was calculated using the diagnostic heuristic of Hyland et al. (2017), on the basis of which ICD-11 PTSD is estimated by means of the IES-R.
Overall, 88 % of the detained men examined had been traumatized during childhood and / or life span; 78 % reported at least one event on the ACE, on average 1.5, with 25 % reporting four or more events. Emotional abuse was reported most frequently (51 %). Furthermore, 71 % reported at least one event on the Cidi list, on average 1.8, with 45 % reporting serious physical threat. The analysis of ICD-11 PTSD was carried out with n = 34 inmates after exclusion of those without a traumatic event and those who did not complete the IES-R, and ICD-11 PTSD was estimated at 26.5 %.
The study shows that imprisoned men are likely to be a high risk group for the development of PTSD even according to the new ICD. Considering the high prevalence of traumatic events and the numerous negative consequences for mental as well as physical health, specific psychotherapeutic programs and a trauma-informed imprisonment are necessary.
预计2018年发布的国际疾病分类(ICD)第11版,根据在线测试版,导致创伤后应激障碍(PTSD)的诊断标准发生了变化。这些变化可能会影响PTSD先前已知的特征,包括患病率。关于被监禁男性中ICD - 11 PTSD的患病率知之甚少。本研究在这个创伤性障碍的高危群体中探讨了这个问题,因为众所周知,与普通人群相比,男性囚犯更容易受到创伤性事件的影响。
在瑞士的49名被监禁男性中,采用横断面和标准化的自我评估程序(ACE、Cidi清单、IES - R)来记录创伤性事件和可能的创伤症状。使用海兰德等人(2017年)的诊断启发法计算ICD - 11 PTSD的频率,在此基础上通过IES - R来估计ICD - 11 PTSD。
总体而言,接受检查的被拘留男性中,88%在童年和/或生命周期中遭受过创伤;78%在ACE上报告至少发生过一次事件,平均为1.5次,25%报告发生过四次或更多事件。情感虐待报告最为频繁(51%)。此外,7...