Alli A, Omar S, Tsang S, Naik B I
Ahmad Alli, MMed, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa.
Shahed Omar, MBBCh, University of the Witwatersrand, Johannesburg, South Africa.
Middle East J Anaesthesiol. 2017 Jun;24(2):119-129.
We conducted this prospective controlled observational study to compare the effect of ethnicity on the risk of postoperative nausea and vomiting (PONV) between moderate to high-risk African and non-African patients undergoing general anesthesia.
Using Apfel score risk factors and predicted length of surgery (>30 minutes), 89 moderate to high risk patients undergoing general anesthesia were recruited in a university hospital between March 2009 and November 2010. Thirty patients in the non-African group and 59 patients in the African group were allocated using an ethnicity self identification questionnaire. Intraoperative anesthesia was standardized. PONV was assessed at 0 minutes, 15 minutes, 90 minutes, 180 minutes, and 24 hours. Generalized linear mixed effects models was used to determine the effect of ethnicity on PONV.
Despite similar Apfel scores, cumulative incidence of postoperative nausea was higher in the non-African group at 0 minutes (46.67% vs 22.03%, 0.019), 15 minutes (70% vs 23.73%, p<0.001) and 90 minutes (36.67% vs 16.95%, = 0.04). The non-African group had more episodes of vomiting over 24 hours (13.33% vs 1.69%, = 0.055). Non-Africans had a 25 times higher reported nausea incidence than Africans over 24 hours.
The incidence of PONV in non-Africans is significantly higher than in Africans. Non-African ethnicity is an independent risk factor for PONV. Current risk prediction models may be limited in multi-ethnic populations and further investigations are warranted to examine ethnicity as a risk factor.
我们开展了这项前瞻性对照观察性研究,以比较种族对接受全身麻醉的中高危非洲裔和非非洲裔患者术后恶心呕吐(PONV)风险的影响。
根据阿佩尔评分风险因素及预计手术时长(>30分钟),于2009年3月至2010年11月在一家大学医院招募了89例接受全身麻醉的中高危患者。使用种族自我识别问卷将30例非非洲裔患者和59例非洲裔患者进行分组。术中麻醉标准化。在0分钟、15分钟、90分钟、180分钟和24小时评估PONV情况。采用广义线性混合效应模型来确定种族对PONV的影响。
尽管阿佩尔评分相似,但非非洲裔组术后恶心的累积发生率在0分钟时更高(46.67%对22.03%,P = 0.019),15分钟时更高(70%对23.73%,P<0.001),90分钟时更高(36.67%对16.95%,P = 0.04)。非非洲裔组在24小时内呕吐发作次数更多(13.33%对1.69%,P = 0.055)。非非洲裔人群报告的恶心发生率在24小时内比非洲裔人群高25倍。
非非洲裔患者PONV的发生率显著高于非洲裔患者。非非洲裔种族是PONV的独立危险因素。当前的风险预测模型在多民族人群中可能存在局限性,有必要进一步开展研究以检验种族作为一个危险因素的情况。