Poulin R
Department of Zoology,University of Otago,P.O. Box 56,Dunedin 9054,New Zealand.
J Helminthol. 2019 Jan;93(1):8-11. doi: 10.1017/S0022149X18000767. Epub 2018 Aug 24.
In recent decades, parasite community ecology has produced hundreds of studies on an ever-growing number of host species, and developed into an active sub-discipline of parasitology. However, this growth has been characterized by a lack of standards in the practices used by researchers, with many common approaches being flawed, unjustified or misleading. Here, in the hope of promoting advances in the study of parasite community ecology, I identify some of the most common errors or weaknesses in past studies, and propose ten simple rules for best practice in the field. They cover issues including, among others, taxonomic resolution, proper and justifiable analytical methods, higher-level replication, controlling for sampling effort or species richness, accounting for spatial distances, using experimental approaches, and placing raw data in the public domain. While knowledge of parasite communities has expanded in breadth, with more and more host species being studied, true progress has been very limited with respect to our understanding of fundamental general processes shaping these communities. It is hoped that the guidelines presented here can direct researchers away from the entrenched use of certain approaches flawed in design, analysis or interpretation, by offering a more rigorous and standardized set of practices, and, hopefully, a way forward.
近几十年来,寄生虫群落生态学针对越来越多的宿主物种开展了数百项研究,并发展成为寄生虫学中一个活跃的子学科。然而,这种发展的特点是研究人员所采用的方法缺乏标准,许多常用方法存在缺陷、不合理或具有误导性。在此,为推动寄生虫群落生态学研究取得进展,我指出了过去研究中一些最常见的错误或不足,并提出了该领域最佳实践的十条简单规则。这些规则涵盖的问题包括分类分辨率、恰当且合理的分析方法、更高层次的重复、控制抽样工作量或物种丰富度、考虑空间距离、采用实验方法以及将原始数据公开等。虽然随着研究的宿主物种越来越多,对寄生虫群落的了解在广度上有所扩展,但在理解塑造这些群落的基本一般过程方面,真正的进展非常有限。希望这里提出的指导方针能够引导研究人员摒弃在设计、分析或解释方面存在缺陷的某些方法的固有使用方式,提供一套更严谨、标准化的实践方法,并有望指明前进的方向。