Ibbotson Paul, López Diana G, McKane Alan J
Childhood, Youth and Sports Group, Open University, Milton Keynes, United Kingdom.
Theoretical Physics Division, School of Physics and Astronomy, University of Manchester, Manchester, United Kingdom.
Front Psychol. 2018 Aug 15;9:1301. doi: 10.3389/fpsyg.2018.01301. eCollection 2018.
Given that there is referential uncertainty (noise) when learning words, to what extent can forgetting filter some of that noise out, and be an aid to learning? Using a Cross Situational Learning model we find a U-shaped function of errors indicative of a "Goldilocks" zone of forgetting: an optimum store-loss ratio that is neither too aggressive nor too weak, but just the right amount to produce better learning outcomes. Forgetting acts as a high-pass filter that actively deletes (part of) the referential ambiguity noise, retains intended referents, and effectively amplifies the signal. The model achieves this performance without incorporating any specific cognitive biases of the type proposed in the constraints and principles account, and without any prescribed developmental changes in the underlying learning mechanism. Instead we interpret the model performance as more of a by-product of exposure to input, where the associative strengths in the lexicon grow as a function of linguistic experience in combination with memory limitations. The result adds a mechanistic explanation for the experimental evidence on spaced learning and, more generally, advocates integrating domain-general aspects of cognition, such as memory, into the language acquisition process.
鉴于在学习单词时存在指称不确定性(噪音),遗忘在多大程度上能够过滤掉其中的一些噪音并有助于学习呢?通过使用一种跨情境学习模型,我们发现了一种呈U形的错误函数,这表明存在一个遗忘的“金发姑娘区”:即一个最佳的存储-损失比率,既不过于激进也不过于微弱,而是恰到好处地能产生更好的学习效果。遗忘起到了高通滤波器的作用,它会主动删除(部分)指称模糊的噪音,保留预期的指称对象,并有效地放大信号。该模型在不纳入约束与原则理论中所提出的任何特定认知偏差的情况下,以及在基础学习机制中没有任何规定的发展变化的情况下实现了这种性能。相反,我们将模型的性能更多地解释为接触输入的一种副产品,其中词汇表中的联想强度随着语言经验与记忆限制的结合而增长。这一结果为间隔学习的实验证据增添了一种机制性解释,更广泛地说,主张将诸如记忆等认知的领域一般性方面整合到语言习得过程中。