Department of Biological Sciences, East Tennessee State University, Johnson City, TN, 37614.
Estación Biológica de Doñana, Consejo Superior de Investigaciones Científicas (EBD-CSIC), Sevilla, Spain.
Am J Bot. 2018 Sep;105(9):1601-1608. doi: 10.1002/ajb2.1144. Epub 2018 Aug 31.
There is growing interest in understanding plant-plant interactions via pollen transfer at the community level. Studies on the structure and spatial variability of pollen transfer networks have been valuable to this understanding. However, there is high variability in the intensity of sampling used to characterize pollen transfer interactions, which could influence network structure. To date, there is no knowledge of how sampling effort influences the richness of pollen on stigmas and thereby transfer interactions observed, nor how this may vary across species and study sites.
We use rarefaction curves on 16 species to characterize the relationship between sampling effort (number of stigmas analyzed) and the richness of pollen transfer interactions recorded. We further assess variability in this relationship among species, plant community types, and sites within a single plant community.
We show high among-species variation in the amount of sampling required to sufficiently characterize interspecific pollen transfer. We further reveal variability in the sampling effort-interaction richness relationship among different plant communities and even for the same species growing in different sites.
The wide heterogeneity in the sampling effort required to accurately characterize pollen transfer interactions observed has the potential to influence the characterization of pollen transfer dynamics. Thus, sampling completeness should be considered in future studies to avoid overestimation of modularity and specialization in pollen transfer networks that may bias the predicted causes and expected consequences of such processes for plant-plant interactions.
人们越来越感兴趣的是通过社区层面的花粉转移来理解植物-植物之间的相互作用。关于花粉转移网络结构和空间变异性的研究对这一理解很有价值。然而,用于描述花粉转移相互作用的采样强度存在很大的可变性,这可能会影响网络结构。迄今为止,人们还不知道采样力度如何影响柱头花粉的丰富度,从而影响观察到的转移相互作用,也不知道这种情况在不同物种和研究地点之间会如何变化。
我们使用 16 个物种的稀疏曲线来描述采样力度(分析的柱头数量)与记录的花粉转移相互作用丰富度之间的关系。我们进一步评估了物种、植物群落类型和同一植物群落内不同地点之间这种关系的变异性。
我们表明,要充分描述种间花粉转移,所需的采样量存在很大的种间差异。我们还揭示了不同植物群落以及同一物种在不同地点生长时,采样力度-相互作用丰富度关系的可变性。
准确描述观察到的花粉转移相互作用所需的采样力度的广泛异质性有可能影响花粉转移动态的描述。因此,在未来的研究中应考虑采样的完整性,以避免对花粉转移网络的模块性和专业化的高估,这可能会对植物-植物相互作用的这些过程的预测原因和预期后果产生偏差。