Orencole Michael J, Nylund Adam M, Moorer Jeremiah D, Wills Robert W, Witsberger Tige H
J Am Vet Med Assoc. 2018 Sep 15;253(6):746-751. doi: 10.2460/javma.253.6.746.
OBJECTIVE To determine whether medial patellar luxation would affect radiographic tibial plateau angle (TPA) measurements in small-breed dogs. DESIGN Prospective cross-sectional study. ANIMALS 15 small-breed dogs (25 stifle joints) with grade 2 or 3 medial patellar luxation (5 dogs with unilateral luxation and 10 dogs with bilateral luxation). PROCEDURES Digital mediolateral radiographic images of each affected stifle joint were acquired with the patella in manually reduced (n = 25) and luxated (25) positions. In 2 measurement sessions separated by > 48 hours, 3 observers unaware of patella status (luxated or reduced) measured the TPA in each image twice in random order. Mixed linear modeling was performed to determine the effect of patella status on TPA measurements, and intraobserver and interobserver variation in measurements were calculated. RESULTS TPA measurements by all observers differed significantly between the first and second measurement sessions, but by a mean value of only 0.7°. A few significant differences were identified between 1 pair of observers by patella status and between patella statuses for 1 observer, but all mean differences were ≤ 1.7°. No significant difference in intraobserver variation was identified between patella statuses for any observer. Interobserver variation was not affected by patella status and measurement session. CONCLUSIONS AND CLINICAL RELEVANCE Although some significant differences were identified in radiographic TPA measurements in dogs with medial patellar luxation, depending on whether the patella was luxated or manually reduced, these differences were so small they could be considered clinically unimportant. Consequently, we believe that in small-breed dogs with patellar luxation, patella status would be unlikely to have a clinically meaningful effect on the measured TPA.
目的 确定内侧髌骨脱位是否会影响小型犬的胫骨平台角(TPA)X线测量结果。 设计 前瞻性横断面研究。 动物 15只患有2级或3级内侧髌骨脱位的小型犬(25个 stifle关节)(5只单侧脱位犬和10只双侧脱位犬)。 方法 对每个受影响的stifle关节在髌骨手动复位(n = 25)和脱位(25)位置时获取数字化内外侧X线图像。在间隔> 48小时的2次测量中,3名不知髌骨状态(脱位或复位)的观察者以随机顺序对每张图像测量TPA两次。进行混合线性建模以确定髌骨状态对TPA测量的影响,并计算观察者内和观察者间测量的变异。 结果 所有观察者在第一次和第二次测量之间的TPA测量值有显著差异,但平均值仅为0.7°。在1对观察者之间根据髌骨状态以及1名观察者在不同髌骨状态之间发现了一些显著差异,但所有平均差异均≤1.7°。对于任何观察者,在不同髌骨状态下观察者内变异均无显著差异。观察者间变异不受髌骨状态和测量次数的影响。 结论及临床意义 尽管在患有内侧髌骨脱位的犬的X线TPA测量中发现了一些显著差异,这取决于髌骨是脱位还是手动复位,但这些差异非常小,可认为在临床上不重要。因此,我们认为在患有髌骨脱位的小型犬中,髌骨状态不太可能对测量的TPA产生具有临床意义的影响。