Goodwin Jeff E, Goggin Noreen L
1 University of North Texas, Denton, TX, USA.
2 Independent Contractor, Tallahassee, FL.
Percept Mot Skills. 2018 Dec;125(6):1160-1172. doi: 10.1177/0031512518795758. Epub 2018 Sep 7.
This investigation manipulated concurrent visual feedback for older adults learning to perform a continuous balance task. We randomly assigned 21 older adults to one of three knowledge of results (KR) groups with varying concurrent but always 100% terminal feedback percentages during acquisition: 100% Concurrent and Terminal (100% C&T), 50% Concurrent and 100% Terminal (50% C & 100% T), and 0% Concurrent and 100% Terminal (0% C & 100% T). The continuous balance task involved learning to maintain balance on a circular platform that moved simultaneously on both anterior/posterior and medial/lateral axes. We tested participants before acquisition phase learning and two days afterwards (retention test). At retention testing, participants in the 50% C & 100% T and those in the 0% C & 100% T conditions demonstrated significantly greater accuracy and stability than did participants in the 100% C&T condition. These findings extend previous research with young adults in supporting the guidance theory that too frequent a provision of concurrent knowledge of results negatively affects learning.
本研究对老年人学习执行连续平衡任务时的同步视觉反馈进行了操控。我们将21名老年人随机分配到三个结果知识(KR)组之一,在习得阶段,这三组的终端反馈百分比均为100%,但同步反馈百分比各不相同:100%同步和终端(100% C&T)、50%同步和100%终端(50% C & 100% T)以及0%同步和100%终端(0% C & 100% T)。连续平衡任务包括学习在一个圆形平台上保持平衡,该平台会同时在前/后和内/外轴上移动。我们在习得阶段学习前和两天后(保持测试)对参与者进行了测试。在保持测试中,50% C & 100% T组和0% C & 100% T组的参与者比100% C&T组的参与者表现出显著更高的准确性和稳定性。这些发现扩展了之前对年轻人的研究,支持了指导理论,即过于频繁地提供同步结果知识会对学习产生负面影响。