Department of Urology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, USA.
Department of Urology, University of Michigan, Ann Arbor, MI 48109, USA.
J Sex Med. 2018 Oct;15(10):1403-1413. doi: 10.1016/j.jsxm.2018.08.001. Epub 2018 Sep 5.
Although pediatric urologists have taken responsibility for initiating discussions on sexual and reproductive health with spina bifida patients, research shows that very few girls and women with spina bifida have ever discussed this topic with any physician.
We sought to better understand pediatric urologists' gaps in knowledge and training needs in the sexual and reproductive health education of women with spina bifida with the goal of creating a tool kit to equip providers to have these discussions.
In this qualitative study, pediatric urologists were interviewed separately about their current practices, perceived barriers, knowledge gaps, and recommendations for the tool kit until thematic saturation was reached. The interviews were recorded and transcribed verbatim, then analyzed using grounded theory by 3 independent reviewers.
To evaluate the perspectives and practices of pediatric urologists, we identified the overlapping themes of the interviews. Consensus on themes was reached.
10 Pediatric urologists participated in the study, including 5 men and 5 women, of whom 4 were fellows and 6 were attending physicians (mean years of practice 18, range 6-31 years). The mean number of patients followed up in the respective spina bifida clinics or by the provider was 434 (range 24-1,500). The following themes regarding pediatric urologists' experience providing sexual and reproductive health education to women with spina bifida emerged. Pediatric urologists': (i) lack of formal training; (ii) knowledge gaps such as spina bifida sexuality, fertility, and pregnancy experience; (iii) barriers to having sexual and reproductive health conversations such as lack of comfort and lack of time; (iv) facilitators of these conversations such as a long-term relationship with the patient and the patient's own initiative; (v) desire to learn and provide competent care; and (vi) recommendations for a web-based tool kit that would include content to address the knowledge gaps and training about how to start sexual and reproductive health conversations.
These findings can provide the beginning concepts for the development of training on providing sexual and reproductive health education for pediatric urologists' care for women with spina bifida.
STRENGTHS & LIMITATIONS: This study gives the perspectives of 10 pediatric urologists with a diversity of backgrounds, but all of whom care for a large number of spina bifida patients. This does not give the perspectives of the spina bifida women themselves, which will be evaluated in the next phase of the study.
Pediatric urologists are not trained and do not feel prepared to provide sexual and reproductive health education for girls and women with spina bifida. However, they do see it as their scope of practice and wish to acquire competence in this area. Streur CS, Schafer CL, Garcia VP, et al. "I Don't Know What I'm Doing… I Hope I'm Not Just an Idiot": The Need to Train Pediatric Urologists to Discuss Sexual and Reproductive Health Care With Young Women With Spina Bifida. J Sex Med 2018;15:1403-1413.
尽管小儿泌尿科医生已经开始负责与脊柱裂患者讨论性和生殖健康问题,但研究表明,很少有脊柱裂女孩和妇女曾与任何医生讨论过这个话题。
我们旨在更好地了解小儿泌尿科医生在女性脊柱裂患者性和生殖健康教育方面的知识差距和培训需求,目标是创建一个工具包,使提供者能够进行这些讨论。
在这项定性研究中,小儿泌尿科医生分别接受了关于他们当前实践、感知障碍、知识差距和工具包建议的采访,直到达到主题饱和。采访进行了录音并逐字记录,然后由 3 名独立评论员使用扎根理论进行分析。
为了评估小儿泌尿科医生的观点和做法,我们确定了采访的重叠主题。对主题达成了共识。
10 名小儿泌尿科医生参与了这项研究,包括 5 名男性和 5 名女性,其中 4 名为研究员,6 名为主治医生(平均从业年限 18 年,范围 6-31 年)。各自的脊柱裂诊所或由提供者随访的患者人数平均为 434 人(范围 24-1500 人)。小儿泌尿科医生提供性和生殖健康教育的经验出现了以下主题。小儿泌尿科医生:(i)缺乏正规培训;(ii)知识差距,如脊柱裂的性行为、生育和怀孕经历;(iii)进行性和生殖健康对话的障碍,如缺乏舒适度和缺乏时间;(iv)促进这些对话的因素,如与患者的长期关系和患者的主动;(v)学习和提供有能力的护理的愿望;以及(vi)关于网络工具包的建议,该工具包将包括解决知识差距的内容和关于如何开始性和生殖健康对话的培训。
这些发现可以为小儿泌尿科医生为脊柱裂女性提供性和生殖健康教育提供培训的开始概念。
这项研究提供了 10 名具有不同背景的小儿泌尿科医生的观点,但他们都照顾了大量的脊柱裂患者。这并没有给出脊柱裂女性本身的观点,这将在研究的下一阶段进行评估。
小儿泌尿科医生没有接受培训,也没有感到有准备为患有脊柱裂的女孩和妇女提供性和生殖健康教育。然而,他们确实认为这是他们的实践范围,并希望在这一领域获得能力。