National Institute of Public Health, University of Southern Denmark, Copenhagen, Denmark.
Scand J Public Health. 2019 Dec;47(8):885-889. doi: 10.1177/1403494818799837. Epub 2018 Sep 17.
Review studies on the long-term effects of school-based smoking interventions show mixed results. X:IT was a three-year cluster randomized controlled trial to prevent uptake of smoking among Danish students from age 13 years until age 15 years which previously proved effective in preventing smoking after the first year of intervention. The aim of this paper was to conduct the pre-planned analyses of the effects of the X:IT intervention on smoking after the second year. We used self-reported questionnaire data from students at baseline, first, second, and third follow-up ( at second follow-up=3269, response rate=79.4%). Data from third follow-up were not suitable for analysis. Outcome measure: 'current smoking', dichotomised into smoke daily, weekly, monthly or more seldom versus do not smoke. We performed multilevel, logistic regression analyses of available cases and intention-to-treat (ITT) analyses, replacing missing outcome values by multiple imputation. The prevalence of smoking increased from 5.8% at baseline to 17.0% at second follow-up among students at intervention schools, and from 7.6% to 18.7% among students at control schools. Analyses of available cases and ITT analyses did not support X:IT being effective in preventing smoking after the second year of intervention.
对基于学校的吸烟干预长期效果的研究显示结果不一。X:IT 是一项为期三年的群组随机对照试验,旨在预防丹麦学生从 13 岁到 15 岁期间开始吸烟,该试验先前已被证明在干预后的第一年能有效预防吸烟。本文的目的是对 X:IT 干预对第二年吸烟的效果进行预先计划的分析。我们使用了来自基线、第一次、第二次和第三次随访(第二次随访=3269 人,应答率=79.4%)的学生自我报告问卷数据。第三次随访的数据不适合分析。结局指标:“当前吸烟”,分为每日、每周、每月或更不频繁吸烟与不吸烟。我们对可用病例和意向治疗(ITT)分析进行了多层次逻辑回归分析,并通过多次插补替换缺失的结局值。在干预学校的学生中,吸烟率从基线时的 5.8%上升到第二年随访时的 17.0%,在对照学校的学生中,吸烟率从 7.6%上升到 18.7%。可用病例分析和 ITT 分析均不支持 X:IT 在干预后的第二年预防吸烟的有效性。