Institute of Pharmacology and Toxicology, University of Zurich, Winterthurerstrasse 190, CH-8057, Zurich, Switzerland.
Laboratory of Genetic Neuropharmacology, McLean Hospital, 115 Mill Street, Belmont, MA, 02478, USA; Department of Psychiatry, Harvard Medical School, 401 Park Drive, Boston, MA, 02215, USA.
Neuropharmacology. 2018 Dec;143:71-78. doi: 10.1016/j.neuropharm.2018.09.026. Epub 2018 Sep 18.
Benzodiazepines (BDZ), which potentiate the action of GABA at four subtypes of GABA receptors (α1, α2, α3, and α5GABARs), are highly effective against anxiety disorders, but also cause severe side effects greatly limiting their clinical application. Both, preclinical studies in genetically engineered mice, and preclinical and clinical trials with subtype-selective compounds indicate that undesired effects can in principle be avoided by targeting specific GABAR subtypes. While there is general consensus that activity at α1GABARs should be avoided, controversy exists as to whether α2 or α3GABARs need to be targeted for anxiolysis. While previous experiments in GABAR point-mutated mice demonstrated a critical role of α2GABARs, studies solely relying on pharmacological approaches suggested a dominant contribution of α3GABARs. As most α1GABAR-sparing BDZ site agonists discriminate little between α2 and α3GABARs, these claims rest almost exclusively on a single compound, TP003, that has been reported to be a selective α3GABAR modulator. Here, we have revisited the in vitro pharmacological profile of TP003 and, in addition, tested TP003 in GABAR triple point-mutated mice, in which only either α1, α2, or α3GABARs were left BDZ sensitive. These experiments revealed that TP003 behaves as a partial, rather non-selective BDZ site agonist in vitro that acts in vivo through α1, α2, and α3GABARs (α5GABAR-mediated effects were not tested). With respect to anxiolysis, our results support a critical contribution of α2GABARs, but not of α3GABARs. TP003 should therefore not be considered an α3GABAR selective agent. Previously published studies using TP003 should be interpreted with caution.
苯二氮䓬类药物(BDZ)通过作用于 GABA 受体的四个亚型(α1、α2、α3 和 α5GABARs)增强 GABA 的作用,对治疗焦虑症非常有效,但也会引起严重的副作用,极大地限制了其临床应用。基因工程小鼠的临床前研究、亚类选择性化合物的临床前和临床试验均表明,通过靶向特定的 GABAR 亚型,可以在原理上避免不良作用。虽然普遍认为应该避免 α1GABARs 的活性,但对于是否需要靶向 α2 或 α3GABARs 来进行焦虑缓解仍存在争议。虽然 GABAR 点突变小鼠的先前实验证明了 α2GABARs 的关键作用,但仅依赖药理学方法的研究表明 α3GABARs 具有主导作用。由于大多数 α1GABAR 保留的 BDZ 结合位点激动剂对 α2 和 α3GABARs 的区分很小,这些说法几乎完全基于一种化合物 TP003,该化合物被报道为一种选择性的 α3GABAR 调节剂。在这里,我们重新研究了 TP003 的体外药理学特征,并在 GABAR 三重点突变小鼠中测试了 TP003,其中只有 α1、α2 或 α3GABARs 对 BDZ 敏感。这些实验表明,TP003 在体外表现为部分而非选择性的 BDZ 结合位点激动剂,在体内通过 α1、α2 和 α3GABARs 起作用(未测试 α5GABAR 介导的作用)。就焦虑缓解而言,我们的结果支持 α2GABARs 的关键作用,但不支持 α3GABARs。因此,TP003 不应被视为 α3GABAR 选择性药物。以前使用 TP003 的研究应该谨慎解释。