Department of Sociology, Utrecht University, Utrecht, The Netherlands.
RAND Europe, Westbrook Centre, Cambridge, United Kingdom.
Aggress Behav. 2019 Jan;45(1):82-92. doi: 10.1002/ab.21799. Epub 2018 Oct 3.
A great deal of research shows that adolescent and adult males are more likely to engage in physical aggression and violence than females are. However, few studies have examined cross-cultural variation in sex differences, particularly among low- and middle-income countries [LMICs]. Based on social role and sexual selection theories, we derived two hypotheses regarding possible variations in sex differences across societal contexts: 1) sex differences increase with societal gender polarization (social role theory) and 2) sex differences are exacerbated in societies where socio-economic opportunities are scarce, unequal, or insecure (prediction derived from sexual selection theory). The current study examined the prevalence of and variation in sex differences in physical aggression, as measured by frequent fighting, among 247,909 adolescents in 63 low- and middle-income countries. The results show that, overall, males were over twice as likely (OR = 2.68; 95% CI = 2.60-2.76) to report frequent fighting in the past 12 months than females. However, sex differences vary significantly across LMICs, wherein countries with higher female prevalence rates have smaller sex differences in frequent fighting. Contrary to expectations derived from social role theory, sex differences in physical aggression decrease as societal gender inequality increased. In regards to sexual selection theory, we find no evidence that sex differences in frequent fighting varies according to societal rule of law or income inequality.
大量研究表明,青少年和成年男性比女性更有可能实施身体攻击和暴力行为。然而,很少有研究考察过跨文化性别差异的变化,特别是在中低收入国家[LMICs]。基于社会角色和性选择理论,我们得出了两个关于社会背景下性别差异可能变化的假设:1)性别差异随着社会性别两极化而增加(社会角色理论),2)性别差异在社会经济机会稀缺、不平等或不安全的社会中加剧(性选择理论预测)。本研究考察了 63 个中低收入国家的 247909 名青少年在过去 12 个月中频繁打架的身体攻击性别差异的流行程度和变化。结果表明,总体而言,男性报告过去 12 个月内频繁打架的可能性是女性的两倍多(OR=2.68;95%CI=2.60-2.76)。然而,性别差异在中低收入国家之间存在显著差异,其中女性患病率较高的国家,频繁打架的性别差异较小。与社会角色理论的预期相反,随着社会性别不平等的增加,身体攻击的性别差异会减小。关于性选择理论,我们没有发现证据表明频繁打架的性别差异会根据社会法治或收入不平等而变化。