Tzioumis Vicky, Freire Rafael, Hood Jennifer, Johnson A Jane, Lloyd Janice, Phillips Clive J C, McGreevy Paul D
School of Physics, Faculty of Science, University of Sydney, NSW 2006 Australia. Email:
School of Animal & Veterinary Sciences, Charles Sturt University-Sutherland Laboratories, Wagga Wagga NSW 2650 Australia.
J Vet Med Educ. 2018 Winter;45(4):448-463. doi: 10.3138/jvme.0117-017r. Epub 2018 Oct 4.
The current study was designed to explore the importance that veterinary science educators in Australian and New Zealand universities assign to animal welfare and ethics (AWE) topics as Day One/Initial Competences for new graduates. An online questionnaire was deployed in parallel with an equivalent study of veterinary science students at these educators' schools. Responses were received from 142 educators (51% females =72 and 49% males =70), representing an overall participation rate of 25%. Questions were clustered according to seven areas of veterinary employment: general practice, production animals, companion animals, wild animals, aquatic animals, animals kept for scientific purposes, and animals used in sport and recreation. The most highly rated topics for each of these clusters were: in general practice, e in companion animals, s in production animals, in animals in the wild, in aquatic animals; in animals kept for scientific purposes, and in sport and recreation. Female educators rated many of the topics as significantly more important than did their male counterparts. Educators teaching one or more ethics-related subjects were less likely to rate and as important as those not teaching these subjects. The educators' focus on practical issues clashes with a perceived need for veterinarians to actively embrace animal ethics. Overall, the perspectives of these educators should be carefully considered as they are likely to influence student attitudes.
本研究旨在探讨澳大利亚和新西兰大学的兽医学教育工作者将动物福利和伦理(AWE)主题作为新毕业生入职第一天/初始能力的重要性。在对这些教育工作者所在学校的兽医学学生进行同等研究的同时,开展了一项在线问卷调查。共收到142名教育工作者的回复(女性占51% = 72人,男性占49% = 70人),总体参与率为25%。问题根据兽医就业的七个领域进行分类:一般实践、生产动物、伴侣动物、野生动物、水生动物、用于科学目的的动物以及用于体育和娱乐的动物。这些类别中每个类别的最高评分主题分别为:一般实践中为 ,伴侣动物中为 ,生产动物中为 ,野生动物中为 ,水生动物中为 ,用于科学目的的动物中为 ,体育和娱乐中为 。女性教育工作者对许多主题的评分明显高于男性同行。教授一门或多门与伦理相关课程的教育工作者比未教授这些课程的教育工作者更不可能将 和 评为重要。教育工作者对实际问题的关注与兽医积极接受动物伦理的认知需求相冲突。总体而言,这些教育工作者的观点应得到仔细考虑,因为它们可能会影响学生的态度。