Jurča J, Havlas V
Ortopedické oddělení Nemocnice v Chomutově, Krajská zdravotní, a.s., Chomutov.
Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech. 2018;85(2):125-129.
PURPOSE OF THE STUDY The aim of the study was to present the surgical technique combining the interposition and suspension arthroplasty using the TIE-IN implant as a treatment option for advanced symptomatic to final stage rhizarthrosis. MATERIAL AND METHODS Since 2015 we have performed the interposition arthroplasty combined with suspension arthroplasty using the TIE-IN implant in 12 patients, mostly indicated for stage IV rhizarthrosis. In two cases stage III rhizarthrosis with concomitant trapezium destruction was present. In two other cases the patients suffered from secondary osteoarthrosis associated with rheumatoid arthritis. Pain under loads was present in all the patients, of whom in 10 patients also the pain at rest occurred. Preoperatively, a total of 10 patients showed subluxation of the first carpometacarpal joint of 50% of the articular surface width. The ratio between the dominant and non-dominant extremity was 1:1. As a part of the evaluation, correlation was established between the preoperative findings and the postoperative results at 3 months follow-up. The examination included the assessment of pain intensity by VAS scale, the range of motion measurement - by Kapandji thumb opposition test, handgrip strength test and functional evaluation using the scoring systems - DASH score, modified DASH score for thumb, and modified Wrightington score. RESULTS No intraoperative or postoperative complications such as infection, complex regional pain syndrome, implant failure or failed surgical procedure were reported in the given group of patients. The pain at rest ceased in all 12 patients. The VAS pain intensity score improved from the preoperative average of 5.8 to 0.8 postoperatively. The range of motion in all the patients with stage IV rhizarthrosis substantially improved. The average Kapandji thumb opposition score increased from 6.9 preoperatively to 9.5 postoperatively. DISCUSSION There are multiple surgical treatment options for advanced rhizarthrosis. Apart from the combination of interposition and suspension arthroplasty referred to above, it is trapeziometacarpal (TMC) arthrodesis on the one hand and carpometacarpal joint total arthroplasty on the other hand. The arthrodesis continues to be a fairly frequently used procedure, despite the final limitation of thumb movement. It is because of this loss of fine motor function why it is not the preferred technique for treating advanced rhizarthrosis at our department. On the very contrary, the total replacement of the TMC joint is at our department as well as at many other departments the treatment of choice for advanced symptomatic rhizarthrosis since in conservative resection of the articular surfaces the biomechanics of the carpometacarpal joint of the thumb is preserved. As an outcome, this technique combines the advantages of other surgical methods by ensuring full painless range of motion and strength of the joint as opposed to other techniques, which mostly result either in a limited movement, or in a loss of grip strength. There is a whole range of resection arthroplasty techniques available. From simple trapeziectomy, which leads to the radial column collapse and ultimately to a major functional deficit, up to various interposition or suspension arthroplasty techniques with the resulting range of motion, stability and thus grip strength depending on the technique applied. CONCLUSIONS By applying the combination of the interposition and suspension arthroplasty of the carpometacarpal joint of the thumb using the TIE-IN implant we preserve the length of the thumb, its stability, and thus achieve the recovery of adequate thumb range of motion and grip strength. Our conclusions are in correlation with the results obtained at reference centres. Key words:rhizarthrosis, trapeziometacarpal prosthesis, arthroplasty, trapezium implant.
研究目的 本研究的目的是介绍一种手术技术,即使用TIE-IN植入物将间置和悬吊关节成形术相结合,作为晚期症状性至终末期拇指腕掌关节病的一种治疗选择。
材料与方法 自2015年以来,我们对12例患者实施了使用TIE-IN植入物的间置关节成形术联合悬吊关节成形术,这些患者大多为IV期拇指腕掌关节病。2例为III期拇指腕掌关节病合并大多角骨破坏。另外2例患者患有与类风湿关节炎相关的继发性骨关节炎。所有患者均存在负重时疼痛,其中10例患者休息时也疼痛。术前,共有10例患者的第一腕掌关节半脱位达关节面宽度的50%。优势手与非优势手的比例为1:1。作为评估的一部分,在术后3个月随访时建立术前检查结果与术后结果之间的相关性。检查包括采用视觉模拟评分法(VAS)评估疼痛强度、通过卡潘迪拇指对掌试验测量活动范围、握力测试以及使用评分系统进行功能评估——DASH评分、拇指改良DASH评分和改良Wrightington评分。
结果 在所研究的患者组中,未报告术中或术后并发症,如感染、复杂性区域疼痛综合征、植入物失败或手术失败。所有12例患者休息时的疼痛均消失。VAS疼痛强度评分从术前的平均5.8改善至术后的0.8。所有IV期拇指腕掌关节病患者的活动范围均有显著改善。卡潘迪拇指对掌平均评分从术前的6.9提高至术后的9.5。
讨论 对于晚期拇指腕掌关节病有多种手术治疗选择。除上述间置和悬吊关节成形术的联合外,一方面是大多角骨 -掌骨关节融合术,另一方面是腕掌关节全关节置换术。尽管拇指活动最终受限,但融合术仍是一种相当常用的手术。正是由于这种精细运动功能的丧失,它不是我们科室治疗晚期拇指腕掌关节病的首选技术。相反,在我们科室以及许多其他科室,TMC关节全置换术是晚期症状性拇指腕掌关节病的首选治疗方法,因为在关节面的保守切除中,拇指腕掌关节的生物力学得以保留。因此,该技术结合了其他手术方法的优点,与其他大多导致活动受限或握力丧失的技术相反,它能确保关节完全无痛的活动范围和力量。有一系列的切除关节成形术技术可供选择。从简单的大多角骨切除术(可导致桡侧柱塌陷并最终导致严重功能缺陷)到各种间置或悬吊关节成形术技术,其活动范围、稳定性以及握力取决于所应用的技术。
结论 通过应用使用TIE-IN植入物的拇指腕掌关节间置和悬吊关节成形术的联合,我们保留了拇指的长度及其稳定性,从而实现了拇指活动范围和握力的充分恢复。我们的结论与参考中心获得的结果相关。
拇指腕掌关节病;大多角骨 -掌骨假体;关节成形术;大多角骨植入物