Závodský I, Pavličný R, Holinka M
Ortopedické oddělení, Karvinská Hornická Nemocnice, a.s., Karviná - Nové Město.
Acta Chir Orthop Traumatol Cech. 2018;85(2):130-136.
PURPOSE OF THE STUDY Trapeziometacarpal osteoarthritis affects primarily postmenopausal middle-aged and older women. Total joint replacement is one of the surgical treatment options for symptomatic advanced degenerative changes of the carpometacarpal joint. This study aims to evaluate the short-term functional and radiological results of the Ivory ® prosthesis with the minimum followup period of three years after the surgery. MATERIAL AND METHODS Presented are the results of 48 total trapeziometacarpal joint replacements in the group of 40 patients composed of 36 women and 4 men. The age of patients ranges from 41 to 75 years (median 56 years), with the ratio between the dominant and non-dominant upper extremity 23:25. The follow-up period ranged from 36 to 63 months (median 52 months). The surgery was indicated in patients with symptomatic trapeziometacarpal arthrosis of stage II, III and early stage IV according to Eaton-Glickel once the conservative therapy had failed. In all the patients, the evaluation of the function and pain of the operated joint by DASH score, the range of motion -thumb opposition by Kapandji score were carried out at regular intervals pre- and postoperatively, the radiological evaluation of the stage of degenerative joint condition was done preoperatively, whereas the position of the implant and the lengthening of the first column of the finger were assessed postoperatively. RESULTS Subjectively, the patients were satisfied with the result of the surgery. After the joint replacement, in 65% of cases the patients reported full satisfaction with no difficulties present, in 31% of cases the patients suffered from pain during loading, in 4% of cases the patients reported also occasional pain at rest. Postoperatively, the total DASH score values decreased from the mean preoperative value of 52.79 to 10.4 points at a three-year follow-up. The average value of pain dropped from 3.46 to 1.44 points 3 years after the surgery. The average range of motion - thumb opposition by Kapandji score increased from 8.57/10 to 9.85/10 one year after the surgery. The difference between the values of average increase in length of the first column of the finger was 0.14 mm in favour of the sub-group of symptomatic cases. In the evaluated group, the need for revision was determined in 4 implants. In 1case for aseptic loosening of the cup and three times for dislocation. After 36 months, 47 of 48 implants were in situ, the overall three-year survival was achieved in 97.9%. The most frequent postoperative complication was the occurrence of De Quervain s tenosynovitis (10%). DISCUSSION Currently, most of the newer types of modular uncemented hydroxyapatite-coated total "ball and socket" joint replacements present acceptable medium-term, and in some cases even long-term, results regarding the survival. The most pressing issue continues to be the survival of implants, particularly the failure of the trapezial component and the associated risk of revision surgery. Good postoperative results can be achieved by accurate indication, carefully applied cup implant and good postoperative cooperation of patients. The complementary study did not confirm that the lengthening of the thumb causes the postoperative development of De Quervain s tenosynovitis. CONCLUSIONS The uncemented first carpometacarpal joint total replacement using the Ivory ® prosthesis brings about very good shortterm functional and radiological results, with no occurrence of early aseptic loosening of the implant. Key words:rhizarthrosis, arthroplasty, carpometacarpal joint prosthesis, uncemented.
研究目的
第一掌腕关节骨关节炎主要影响绝经后的中老年女性。全关节置换是腕掌关节有症状的晚期退行性变的手术治疗选择之一。本研究旨在评估Ivory®假体术后至少三年的短期功能和影像学结果。
材料与方法
介绍了40例患者中48例第一掌腕关节全置换的结果,其中女性36例,男性4例。患者年龄在41至75岁之间(中位数56岁),优势上肢与非优势上肢的比例为23:25。随访期为36至63个月(中位数52个月)。根据伊顿 - 格利克尔(Eaton - Glickel)分级,对于II期、III期和早期IV期有症状的第一掌腕关节病患者,一旦保守治疗失败即行手术。所有患者在术前和术后定期通过DASH评分评估手术关节的功能和疼痛,通过卡潘迪(Kapandji)评分评估拇指对掌活动范围,术前对关节退变情况进行影像学评估,术后评估植入物位置和手指第一列的延长情况。
结果
主观上,患者对手术结果满意。关节置换后,65%的患者表示完全满意且无困难,31%的患者在负重时有疼痛,4%的患者表示休息时也偶尔疼痛。术后,三年随访时DASH总分值从术前平均52.79分降至10.4分。术后三年疼痛平均分从3.46分降至1.44分。术后一年,卡潘迪评分的拇指对掌平均活动范围从8.57/10增加到9.85/10。手指第一列平均延长增加值在有症状病例亚组中更有利,差值为0.14mm。在评估组中,4枚植入物确定需要翻修。1例因髋臼无菌性松动,3例因脱位。36个月后,48枚植入物中有47枚在位,三年总生存率为97.9%。最常见的术后并发症是桡骨茎突狭窄性腱鞘炎(发生率10%)。
讨论
目前,大多数新型模块化非骨水泥羟基磷灰石涂层全“球窝”关节置换在生存率方面呈现出可接受的中期,甚至在某些情况下是长期结果。最紧迫的问题仍然是植入物的生存率,特别是大多角骨部件的失败以及相关的翻修手术风险。通过准确的适应症选择、精心应用髋臼植入物以及患者良好的术后配合,可以取得良好的术后效果。补充研究未证实拇指延长会导致术后桡骨茎突狭窄性腱鞘炎的发生。
结论
使用Ivory®假体进行非骨水泥第一腕掌关节全置换带来了非常好的短期功能和影像学结果,且未发生植入物早期无菌性松动。
拇指腕掌关节病,关节成形术,腕掌关节假体,非骨水泥