Carli Alberto, Moretti Francesca, Giovanazzi Giulia, Niero Valentina, Perilli Valeria, Ghirlanda Giovanna, Bovo Chiara, Tardivo Stefano
School of Specialization in Hygiene and Preventive Medicine - University of Verona.
Acta Biomed. 2018 Oct 8;89(3):430-436. doi: 10.23750/abm.v89i3.7596.
Patients could leave ED not receiving the desired care either Without Being Seen by a doctor (LWBS) or Against Medical Advice (DAMA). In term of care quality, LWBS may be related to inappropriate access and process of care, while DAMA may lead to increased risk of mortality and re-admissions. This study aims to identify frequency of patients who leave ED, determine their characteristics and identify associated factor.
This was a retrospective observational study of patients that attended EDs of University Hospital Trust of Verona in 2017. Demographic and ED access associated variables were collected for LWBS, DAMA and completed-ED-treatment patients. Univariate and multivariate data analyses was based on EMUR-PS administrative data.
5,901 of 127,180 ED accesses were uncompleted treatment (4.64%); LWBS were 4,664 (79.04%) and DAMA 1,237 (20.96%). Those who leave ED tended to be younger (39.35 vs. 45.56, p<0.01). Independent factors associated with ED leaving resulted: i) non-urgent triage category (OR: 2.941, 95%CI: 2.405-3.596) ii) non-Italian-nationality (OR: 1.695, 95%CI: 1.493-1.924) and requiring psychiatric consult (OR:6.16 95%IC 4.82-7.87); while protective factors resulted: i) female gender (OR: 0.713, 95%CI: 0.633-0.803); i) Paediatric ED (OR: 0.593, 95%CI: 0.437-0.805); ii) Obstetrics-Gynaecology ED (OR: 0.284, 95%CI: 0.193-0.416) iii) inclusion in fast track pathways (OR: 0.747, 95%CI: 0.602-0.927). Higher ED leaving rate were observed during night-time and Sunday, either overcrowding resulted not associated.
Results show the necessity to implement primary care-ED integrated pathway, mainly in frail sub-population, improve awareness on healthcare service use and refine communication skills in ED-team.
患者可能在未得到期望的治疗情况下离开急诊科,即未就诊离开(LWBS)或违反医嘱离开(DAMA)。在医疗质量方面,LWBS可能与不适当的就诊机会和医疗过程有关,而DAMA可能导致死亡风险和再次入院风险增加。本研究旨在确定离开急诊科的患者频率,确定其特征并识别相关因素。
这是一项对2017年在维罗纳大学医院信托急诊科就诊患者的回顾性观察研究。收集了LWBS、DAMA和完成急诊科治疗患者的人口统计学和急诊科就诊相关变量。单变量和多变量数据分析基于EMUR-PS管理数据。
127180次急诊科就诊中有5901次未完成治疗(4.64%);LWBS为4664例(79.04%),DAMA为1237例(20.96%)。离开急诊科的患者往往更年轻(39.35岁对45.56岁,p<0.01)。与离开急诊科相关的独立因素包括:i)非紧急分诊类别(OR:2.941,95%CI:2.405 - 3.596);ii)非意大利国籍(OR:1.695,95%CI:1.493 - 1.924)以及需要精神科会诊(OR:6.16,95%IC:4.82 - 7.87);而保护因素包括:i)女性(OR:0.713,95%CI:0.633 - 0.803);i)儿科急诊科(OR:0.593,95%CI:0.437 - 0.805);ii)妇产科急诊科(OR:0.284,95%CI:0.193 - 0.416);iii)纳入快速通道(OR:0.747,95%CI:0.602 - 0.927)。在夜间和周日观察到较高的离开急诊科率,而过度拥挤与之无关。
结果表明有必要实施初级保健 -急诊科综合路径,主要针对脆弱亚人群,提高对医疗服务使用的认识并提升急诊科团队的沟通技巧。