St Stephens Hospital Delhi, India.
135 Bhagirathi, Sector 9, Rohini, Delhi, India.
Disabil Health J. 2019 Apr;12(2):263-268. doi: 10.1016/j.dhjo.2018.10.003. Epub 2018 Oct 16.
The UN recommends that the 'Washington Group questionnaire (WGQ) on functioning' is used for data collection on disability. There are few studies on the WGQ from India.
To evaluate the prevalence of disability in a community-health project, using this tool: to examine if the use of the WGQ identifies more people with disability than the tools used previously.
We performed a systematic sample survey using the WGQ in the community-health project covering a population of 50,000 residents. The questionnaire was administered to 2203 individuals.
The age and sex distribution of the sample studied matched the National Census data 2011. The study identified 41 individuals with a disability. The prevalence of disability in our sample was 1.86% (95% CI 1.3%-2.43%) compared to 2.21% in India-Census-2011. Receiver operating characteristic (ROC) curve showed that disability was more prevalent after the age of 44 years (p-value <0.0001 and AUC 0.806). The odds ratio of disability was 10.1 above this age compared with those below that age (95% CI: 5.1 to 20).
Use of the WGQ did not yield better data on disability prevalence than that identified by the Census. Another study, this one in Telangana, south India, by the London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine found that self-reporting identifies only a third of the cases of disability. More direct and leading questions are needed to empower the disabled in developing countries to identify barriers which prevent their full participation in society.
联合国建议使用“华盛顿小组功能问卷(WGQ)”收集残疾数据。关于印度的 WGQ 研究较少。
使用该工具评估一个社区卫生项目中的残疾患病率:检验 WGQ 是否比以前使用的工具能识别出更多的残疾人群。
我们在一个覆盖 50000 名居民的社区卫生项目中进行了系统抽样调查,使用 WGQ 对 2203 个人进行了问卷调查。
研究样本的年龄和性别分布与 2011 年全国人口普查数据相匹配。研究共发现 41 名残疾人士。我们的样本中残疾患病率为 1.86%(95%CI 1.3%-2.43%),而印度 2011 年人口普查的残疾患病率为 2.21%。受试者工作特征(ROC)曲线显示,残疾在 44 岁以后更为普遍(p 值<0.0001,AUC 为 0.806)。与 44 岁以下人群相比,44 岁以上人群的残疾患病风险比为 10.1(95%CI:5.1 至 20)。
与人口普查相比,WGQ 并未提供更好的残疾患病率数据。伦敦卫生与热带医学院在印度南部泰伦加纳进行的另一项研究发现,自我报告仅能识别出三分之一的残疾病例。在发展中国家,需要更直接和引导性的问题来赋予残疾人权力,以识别阻碍他们充分参与社会的障碍。