National University of Singapore, Singapore City, Singapore.
Building and Construction Authority, Singapore City, Singapore.
Indoor Air. 2019 Jan;29(1):112-129. doi: 10.1111/ina.12515. Epub 2018 Nov 17.
Indoor environmental quality (IEQ) has become an important component of green building certification schemes. While green buildings are expected to provide enhanced IEQ, higher occupant satisfaction, and less risks of occupant health when compared with non-green buildings, the literature suggests inconsistent evidence due to diverse research design, small sample size, and weak statistical analysis. This study compared several outcomes pertinent to IEQ performance in green and non-green office buildings in Singapore. Adopting a cross-sectional study design, objective measurements were taken in eight green and six non-green buildings, and satisfaction and acute health symptom risks of 367 occupants were obtained. Green buildings exhibited lower concentration of PM2.5, bacteria, and fungi and maintained temperature and humidity more consistently compared to non-green counterparts. The mean ratings for satisfaction with temperature, humidity, lighting level, air quality, and indoor environment were higher in green buildings (with statistical significance P < 0.05). There was statistically significant reduction in risk of occupants having headache, unusual fatigue, and irritated skin in green buildings. Although matching of buildings and occupant characteristics, survey participation bias, and sampling duration (a 1-week snapshot) of IEQ monitoring remain as limitations, this study offered positive association of green buildings with qualitatively and quantitatively measured performance of IEQ.
室内环境质量 (IEQ) 已成为绿色建筑认证计划的重要组成部分。虽然绿色建筑预计将提供更好的 IEQ、更高的居住者满意度以及减少居住者健康风险,但文献表明,由于研究设计、样本量小和统计分析薄弱的多样性,存在不一致的证据。本研究比较了新加坡几座绿色和非绿色办公大楼的几项与 IEQ 性能相关的结果。采用横断面研究设计,在八座绿色建筑和六座非绿色建筑中进行了客观测量,并获得了 367 名居住者的满意度和急性健康症状风险。与非绿色建筑相比,绿色建筑的 PM2.5、细菌和真菌浓度较低,且温度和湿度保持更稳定。绿色建筑中对温度、湿度、光照水平、空气质量和室内环境的满意度评分较高(具有统计学意义 P<0.05)。绿色建筑中居住者头痛、异常疲劳和皮肤刺激的风险明显降低。尽管建筑和居住者特征匹配、调查参与偏差以及 IEQ 监测的采样持续时间(一周的快照)仍然存在局限性,但本研究提供了绿色建筑与 IEQ 的定性和定量测量性能之间的积极关联。