Puljevic Mislav, Danilowicz-Szymanowicz Ludmila, Molon Giulio, Puljevic Davor, Raczak Grzegorz, Canali Guido, Velagic Vedran, Pezo-Nikolic Borka, Milicic Davor
University of Zagreb, School of Medicine, University Hospital Center Zagreb, Zagreb, Croatia.
Department of Cardiology and Electrotherapy, Medical University of Gdansk, Gdansk, Poland.
Ann Noninvasive Electrocardiol. 2019 Mar;24(2):e12610. doi: 10.1111/anec.12610. Epub 2018 Nov 1.
Microvolt T-wave alternans (MTWA) testing is a beat-to-beat fluctuation in the amplitude of T wave. We investigated whether: (a) MTWA can be new non-invasive tool for detection of reversible ischemia in patients with suspected CAD without structural heart disease, (b) MTWA can detect ischemia earlier and with greater test accuracy compared with exercise ECG ST-segment testing, and (c) threshold value of MTWA and heart rate at which the alternans is estimated can be different compared to standard values.
A total of 101 patients with suspected stable coronary disease, but without structural heart disease, were included. Echocardiography, exercise ECG test, MTWA with classical and modified threshold alternans values, and coronary angiography were performed.
About 33.3% patients had a false-positive result on exercise ECG test. The sensitivity of exercise ECG ST-segment test in the detection of coronary artery disease was 97.8%, and the specificity was 42.5% (DOR 33.89). In a group of angiographically positive patients, standard MTWA accurately identified 60% of patients, while 40% had a false-negative result. About 91.8% patients with negative angiography result were accurately identified with 8.2% false positives. The sensitivity of MTWA was 59.61% and specificity 91.83%. Best ratio of sensitivity and specificity (86.53% and 95.91%, DOR 151.06) had modified criteria for positive MTWA (MTWA >1.5 µV at heart rate 115-125/min).
This study showed that MTWA can be the new non-invasive tool for the detection of reversible ischemia in patients with suspected CAD without structural heart disease. Also, MTWA can detect ischemia earlier and with greater accuracy compared with exercise ECG testing.
微伏级T波交替(MTWA)检测是T波振幅的逐搏波动。我们研究了:(a)MTWA是否可作为检测无结构性心脏病的疑似冠心病患者可逆性缺血的新型非侵入性工具;(b)与运动心电图ST段检测相比,MTWA是否能更早且更准确地检测出缺血;(c)与标准值相比,MTWA的阈值及估计交替时的心率是否会有所不同。
纳入101例疑似稳定型冠心病但无结构性心脏病的患者。进行了超声心动图、运动心电图检测、采用经典和改良阈值交替值的MTWA检测以及冠状动脉造影。
约33.3%的患者运动心电图检测结果为假阳性。运动心电图ST段检测诊断冠状动脉疾病的敏感性为97.8%,特异性为42.5%(诊断比值比33.89)。在血管造影阳性的患者组中,标准MTWA准确识别出60%的患者,而40%的患者结果为假阴性。血管造影结果阴性的患者中,约91.8%被准确识别,假阳性率为8.2%。MTWA的敏感性为59.61%,特异性为91.83%。MTWA阳性的改良标准(心率115 - 125次/分钟时MTWA>1.5µV)的敏感性和特异性最佳比值为86.53%和95.91%(诊断比值比151.06)。
本研究表明,MTWA可作为检测无结构性心脏病的疑似冠心病患者可逆性缺血的新型非侵入性工具。此外,与运动心电图检测相比,MTWA能更早且更准确地检测出缺血。