SCALab (UMR CNRS 9193), University of Lille, Domaine Universitaire du Pont de Bois, BP60159, 59653 Villeneuve d'Ascq, France.
FPSE, University of Geneva, 40 Bd Pont d'Arve, CH-1211 Genève 4, Switzerland.
Neuropsychologia. 2018 Dec;121:19-27. doi: 10.1016/j.neuropsychologia.2018.10.025. Epub 2018 Oct 30.
Many studies have described the electrophysiological specificities of print processing in dyslexic readers, mostly using lexical decision tasks. The aim of the present study was twofold: a) to assess for the first time the electrophysiological correlates of print processing in dyslexic adults in the under-investigated context of reading aloud tasks, acknowledged to be especially relevant to investigate phonological processes relatively to lexical decision; and b) to assess whether the electrophysiological specificities described in dyslexic readers in lexical decision correspond to a different neuronal network engaged in print processing. 21 dyslexic university students and matched controls performed a lexical decision task and a reading aloud task on words and pseudowords under EEG recording. In lexical decision, the pattern of results indicates the engagement of similar brain processes between the groups, but with a sub-efficient visual word form processing in dyslexia. In reading aloud, between group differences revealed completely different distributions of the electric field at scalp between the two groups after the N2 time window, suggesting alternative processing strategies in dyslexic readers. Those specificities seem to be related to their core phonological deficits. Crucially, the present results suggest that the nature of electrophysiological divergences in print processing in dyslexic readers vary according to the task: while lexical decision task appears to be well suited to assess divergences in lexical access, reading aloud tasks should also be used in ERP investigation as it allows a better insight into phonological processes and thus be better suited in the framework of the phonological deficit theory of dyslexia.
许多研究已经描述了阅读障碍者在处理印刷品时的特定电生理特征,这些研究主要使用词汇判断任务。本研究旨在评估:a)首次在阅读 aloud 任务中评估阅读障碍者在印刷品处理方面的电生理相关性,阅读 aloud 任务被认为是研究语音过程相对于词汇判断更相关的任务;b)评估在词汇判断中描述的阅读障碍者的电生理特征是否对应于参与印刷品处理的不同神经元网络。21 名阅读障碍大学生和匹配的对照组在 EEG 记录下进行了词汇判断任务和朗读任务。在词汇判断任务中,结果模式表明两组之间存在相似的大脑处理过程,但阅读障碍者的视觉词汇处理效率较低。在朗读任务中,组间差异揭示了两组在 N2 时间窗口后头皮上电场的完全不同分布,表明阅读障碍者采用了替代处理策略。这些特征似乎与他们的核心语音缺陷有关。至关重要的是,目前的结果表明,阅读障碍者在印刷品处理中的电生理差异的性质因任务而异:虽然词汇判断任务似乎非常适合评估词汇访问中的差异,但朗读任务也应该在 ERP 研究中使用,因为它可以更好地了解语音过程,从而更适合在语音缺陷理论框架内研究阅读障碍。