Skoczyński Szymon, Scala Raffaele, Navalesi Paolo
Dept of Pulmonology, School of Medicine in Katowice, The Medical University of Silesia, Katowice, Poland.
Pulmonology and Respiratory Intensive Care Unit, S. Donato Hospital, Arezzo, Italy.
ERJ Open Res. 2018 Nov 2;4(4). doi: 10.1183/23120541.00062-2018. eCollection 2018 Oct.
Noninvasive mechanical ventilation (NIV) is an accepted method of respiratory failure treatment; however, at present, little is known about the global factors limiting NIV application. A survey designed to determine NIV accessibility and limiting factors in world economies and regions was developed. The questionnaire was sent to members of the European Respiratory Society (ERS) Respiratory Intensive Care Assembly and all ERS National Delegates. Replies to the survey were collected from 161 respondents from 46 countries. NIV was found to be provided most frequently by pulmonologists and intensivists. In high-income economies (HIEs), NIV reimbursement in chronic respiratory failure treatment was found to be independent of the underlying disease and supplementary insurance (p<0.0001), whereas in upper-middle-income economies (UMIEs) it was found to be dependent on the underlying disease (p<0.0001). In chronic respiratory failure, NIV was not reimbursed in lower-middle-income economies (LMIEs) (p<0.0001). In LMIEs and UMIEs, the lack of financial resources was the main limiting factor in acute (p=0.007) and chronic respiratory failure (p<0.0001). In the income-level-based assessment, financing was recognised as relevant in LMIEs and UMIEs (p<0.0001), equipment in LMIEs and UMIEs (p=0.03), medical staff in all economies (p=0.02), and legal regulations in LMIEs (p=0.0005). It was confirmed that NIV in acute and chronic respiratory failure is reimbursed based on government regulations in UMIEs and HIEs (p<0.0001), and is not reimbursed and probably will not be reimbursed in the near future in LMIEs (p<0.0001). We conclude that financial constraints are still considered a major limiting factor for NIV use.
无创机械通气(NIV)是一种公认的呼吸衰竭治疗方法;然而,目前对于限制NIV应用的全球因素知之甚少。为此开展了一项旨在确定全球各经济体和地区NIV可及性及限制因素的调查。调查问卷发送给了欧洲呼吸学会(ERS)呼吸重症监护委员会成员及所有ERS国家代表。共收到来自46个国家的161名受访者的回复。结果发现,NIV主要由肺科医生和重症监护医生提供。在高收入经济体(HIEs)中,慢性呼吸衰竭治疗中NIV的报销与基础疾病和补充保险无关(p<0.0001),而在中高收入经济体(UMIEs)中,报销情况则取决于基础疾病(p<0.0001)。在中低收入经济体(LMIEs)中,慢性呼吸衰竭的NIV不予报销(p<0.0001)。在LMIEs和UMIEs中,资金短缺是急性(p=0.007)和慢性呼吸衰竭(p<0.0001)的主要限制因素。在基于收入水平的评估中,资金在LMIEs和UMIEs中被认为是相关因素(p<0.0001),设备在LMIEs和UMIEs中是相关因素(p=0.03),医务人员在所有经济体中是相关因素(p=0.02),法律法规在LMIEs中是相关因素(p=0.0005)。已证实,在UMIEs和HIEs中,急性和慢性呼吸衰竭的NIV报销是基于政府规定(p<0.0001),而在LMIEs中不予报销且在可预见的未来可能也不会报销(p<0.0001)。我们得出结论,资金限制仍然被认为是NIV使用的主要限制因素。