Department of Family and Community Medicine, Thomas Jefferson University, Philadelphia, Pennsylvania.
Popul Health Manag. 2019 Aug;22(4):315-320. doi: 10.1089/pop.2018.0125. Epub 2018 Nov 7.
Cancer screening decisions for older adults should be individualized. However, conducting such complex shared decisions may be challenging for primary care providers (PCPs). Additionally, there is little information about how PCPs make these decisions. This study consisted of a provider survey and chart review to assess current PCP approaches to breast and colorectal cancer (CRC) screening for patients ages ≥75 years. PCP survey questions: panel age, comfort with discussion of screening harms and benefits, screening decision-making process, and discussion style. One hundred charts were chosen from a random sample of male and female patients ages ≥75 with a recent office visit. Chart reviews assessed whether providers recommended screening for breast and/or CRC in patients ages ≥75, if there was a documented screening discussion, and if screening was completed. Fifty-one PCPs completed the survey. PCPs varied in the proportions of older adults they recommended for breast and CRC screening; 90.2% reported feeling very (43.1%) or somewhat (47.1%) comfortable discussing reasons for/against screening with older patients. Top screening considerations: life expectancy (84.3%), patient preference (82.4%), and severity of medical conditions (70.6%). Three-quarters (74.55%) reported a shared decision-making approach with discussion of harms/benefits. Of 61 eligible patients, 8 (13.1%) had a documented discussion regarding mammography; of 58 patients eligible for CRC screening, 7 (12.1%) had a documented discussion. Findings showed inconsistency in PCP approaches to cancer screening in older adults and in documentation of discussion. There is ample room for improvement in standardizing approaches and documentation of cancer screening discussions with older patients.
癌症筛查决策应针对老年人进行个体化制定。然而,对于初级保健提供者(PCP)来说,进行如此复杂的共同决策可能具有挑战性。此外,关于 PCP 如何做出这些决策的信息很少。本研究包括一项提供者调查和图表审查,以评估 PCP 目前针对 75 岁及以上患者进行乳腺癌和结直肠癌(CRC)筛查的方法。PCP 调查问题:小组年龄、讨论筛查危害和益处的舒适度、筛查决策过程和讨论风格。从最近一次就诊的 75 岁及以上男性和女性患者的随机样本中选择了 100 份图表。图表审查评估了提供者是否建议对 75 岁及以上患者进行乳腺癌和/或 CRC 筛查,是否有记录的筛查讨论,以及是否完成了筛查。51 名 PCP 完成了调查。PCP 对他们建议进行乳腺癌和 CRC 筛查的老年患者比例存在差异;90.2%报告称非常(43.1%)或有些(47.1%)舒适地与老年患者讨论筛查的原因/反对意见。主要筛查考虑因素:预期寿命(84.3%)、患者偏好(82.4%)和医疗状况严重程度(70.6%)。四分之三(74.55%)报告采用共同决策方法,讨论危害/益处。在 61 名符合条件的患者中,有 8 名(13.1%)有记录的关于乳房 X 光检查的讨论;在 58 名有资格进行 CRC 筛查的患者中,有 7 名(12.1%)有记录的讨论。研究结果显示,PCP 对老年癌症筛查的方法和对讨论的记录不一致。在与老年患者标准化癌症筛查讨论的方法和记录方面还有很大的改进空间。