Gao Qin Zong, Wang Zhi Wei, Qi Ya Fei, Jin Zheng Yu
Department of Radiology,PUMC Hospital,CAMS and PUMC,Beijing 100730,China.
Zhongguo Yi Xue Ke Xue Yuan Xue Bao. 2018 Oct 30;40(5):651-655. doi: 10.3881/j.issn.1000-503X.10257.
Objective To evaluate the value of virtual monoenergetic(monoE)using dual-layer detector spectrum CT in detecting small lesions in rabbit VX2 liver cancer models.Methods Hepatic VX2 double tumor models were established in 24 New Zealand white rabbits by CT-guided puncture. All the rabbits underwent CT scans by using dual-layer detector CT to generate conventional 120-keV polychromatic images and monoE images with energy levels ranging from 40 to 100 keV during the arterial phase. The quantity of the lesion and measurement of the lesion length as well as the objective evaluations[signal noise ratio(SNR)and contrast noise ratio(CNR)] and the subjective evaluations(overall image quality score)of the image quality were independently measured by two radiologists. The results were compared with pathological findings.Results Pathology confirmed that 30 lesions were successfully established,with an average size of(3.99±0.91)mm. Eighteen(47.40%)and 30(100%)lesions were detected by conventional images and monoE images with energy levels from 40 to 65 keV,respectively. The correlation between the length diameter of fresh pathological specimens and the measurements of lesion length diameter on 40(r=0.948,P=0.000),45(r=0.958,P=0.000),50(r=0.972,P=0.000),55(r=0.952,P=0.000),60(r=0.921,P=0.000),65 keV(r=0.917,P=0.000)monoE images was better than that on conventional images(r=0.206,P=0.270). The subjective evaluation scores of the quality of the 40,45,50,and 55 keV monoE images were 4.50(4.00,4.50)(P=0.000),5.00(5.00,5.00)(P=0.000),5.00(4.50,5.00)(P=0.000),and 4.00(4.00,4.50)(P=0.002),respectively,which were significantly higher than the conventional mixed energy images[3.00(2.50,3.00)]. The objective evaluation of image quality showed that the SNR and CNR of monoE images decreased with the increase of the energy level of the monoE image. The CNR of monoE images with 40(P=0.000),45(P=0.002),and 50 keV(P=0.011)were higher than that of the conventional image. The CNR of monoE images with 40(P=0.000),45(P=0.000),50(P=0.000),and 55 keV(P=0.002)were higher than that of the conventional images.Conclusion Dual-layer detector spectrum CT monoE image in the low-energy state of 45-50 keV can improve the detection rate of small lesions in rabbit hepatic VX2 tumor models with better noise control and provide better image quality compared with conventional polychromatic images.
目的 评估双层探测器光谱CT虚拟单能量成像在兔VX2肝癌模型小病灶检测中的价值。方法 采用CT引导下穿刺法在24只新西兰白兔中建立肝VX2双瘤模型。所有兔子均在动脉期行双层探测器CT扫描,以生成常规120 keV多色图像及能量范围为40100 keV的单能量图像。由两名放射科医师独立测量病灶数量、病灶长度,并对图像质量进行客观评估[信噪比(SNR)和对比噪声比(CNR)]及主观评估(整体图像质量评分)。将结果与病理结果进行比较。结果 病理证实成功建立30个病灶,平均大小为(3.99±0.91)mm。常规图像和能量为4065 keV的单能量图像分别检测出18个(47.40%)和30个(100%)病灶。新鲜病理标本的长径与40(r=0.948,P=0.000)、45(r=0.958,P=0.000)、50(r=0.972,P=0.000)、55(r=0.952,P=0.000)、60(r=0.921,P=0.000)、65 keV(r=0.917,P=0.000)单能量图像上病灶长径测量值的相关性优于常规图像(r=0.206,P=0.270)。40、45、50和55 keV单能量图像质量的主观评估分数分别为4.50(4.00,4.50)(P=0.000)、5.00(5.00,5.00)(P=0.000)、5.00(4.50,5.00)(P=0.000)和4.00(4.00,4.50)(P=0.002),均显著高于常规混合能量图像[3.00(2.50,3.00)]。图像质量的客观评估显示,单能量图像的SNR和CNR随单能量图像能量水平的升高而降低。40(P=0.000)、45(P=0.002)和50 keV(P=0.011)单能量图像的CNR高于常规图像。40(P=0.000)、45(P=0.000)、50(P=0.000)和55 keV(P=0.002)单能量图像的CNR高于常规图像。结论 双层探测器光谱CT在45~50 keV低能量状态下的单能量图像可提高兔肝VX2肿瘤模型中小病灶的检出率,与常规多色图像相比具有更好的噪声控制,图像质量更佳。