Aggressive Behaviors Among Nursing Home Residents: Association With Dementia and Behavioral Health Disorders.

OBJECTIVES

We measured the prevalence and severity of aggressive behaviors (ABs) among nursing home (NH) residents and examined whether individuals with behavioral health disorders were more likely to exhibit aggressive behaviors than others.

SETTING AND PARTICIPANTS

The analytical sample included 3,270,713 first Minimum Data Set (MDS) assessments for residents in 15,706 NHs in 2015.

MEASURES

Individuals were identified as having (1) behavioral health disorders only (hierarchically categorized as schizophrenia/psychosis, bipolar disorder, personality disorder, substance abuse, depression/anxiety); (2) dementia only; (3) behavioral health disorders and dementia; or (4) neither. The Aggressive Behavior Scale (ABS) measured the degree of aggressive behaviors exhibited, based on 4 MDS items (verbal, physical, other behavioral symptoms, and rejection of care). The ABS scores ranged from 0 to 12 reflecting symptom severity as none (ABS score = 0), mild (ABS score = 1-2), moderate (ABS score = 3-5), and severe (ABS score = 6-12). Bivariate comparisons and multinomial logistic regressions were performed.

RESULTS

Residents with behavioral health disorders and dementia had the highest prevalence of ABs (23.1%), followed by dementia only (15.3%), behavioral health disorders only (9.3%), and neither (5.3%). After controlling for individual risk factors and facility covariates, the relative risk of exhibiting severe ABs was 2.47, 5.50, and 9.42 for residents with behavioral health disorders only, dementia only, and behavioral health disorders and dementia, respectively, with a similar pattern for moderate or mild ABs.

CONCLUSIONS

Residents with behavioral health disorders were less likely than residents with dementia to exhibit aggressive behaviors in nursing homes. Thus, anecdotally reported concerns that aggressive behaviors are primarily an issue for residents with behavioral health disorders, rather than those with dementia, were not empirically justified.