Gruffi T R, Peralta F M, Thakkar M S, Arif A, Anderson R F, Orlando B, Coffman J C, Nathan N, McCarthy R J, Toledo P, Habib A S
Department of Anesthesiology, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, IL, United States.
Department of Anesthesiology, Northwestern University Feinberg School of Medicine, Chicago, IL, United States.
Int J Obstet Anesth. 2019 Feb;37:52-56. doi: 10.1016/j.ijoa.2018.10.002. Epub 2018 Oct 10.
Consensus regarding the safest mode of delivery and anesthetic management for parturients with Arnold Chiari malformation-I (ACM-I) remains controversial. This study assessed their anesthetic management and reported anesthetic complications during hospitalization for delivery.
This was a multicenter, retrospective, cohort study of patients with ACM-I undergoing vaginal or cesarean delivery. Data were obtained from the electronic databases of four United States academic institutions using International Classification of Diseases (ICD) codes from 2007-2017 at three sites and 2004-2017 at one site. The primary outcome was anesthetic complications.
Data were analyzed for 185 deliveries in 148 patients. Diagnosis of ACM-I was made prior to delivery in 147 (80%) cases. Pre-delivery neurosurgical consultation for management of ACM-I was performed in 53 (36%) patients. Pre-existing symptoms were recorded for 89 (48%) of the deliveries. Vaginal deliveries occurred in 80 (43%) cases, and 62 women (78%) received neuraxial labor analgesia. Cesarean delivery was performed in 105 (57%) cases, of which 70 women (67%) had neuraxial anesthesia and 34 (32%) received general anesthesia. Post-dural puncture headache was reported in three (2%) patients who had neuraxial anesthesia, and in two (12%) patients with syringomyelia. There was one (3%) reported case of aspiration pneumonia with general anesthesia.
The findings suggest that anesthetic complications occur infrequently in patients with ACM-I regardless of the anesthetic management. Although institutional preference in anesthetic and obstetric care appears to drive patient management, the findings suggest that an individualized approach has favorable outcomes in this population.
对于患有Ⅰ型阿诺德-基亚里畸形(ACM-Ⅰ)的产妇,关于最安全的分娩方式和麻醉管理的共识仍存在争议。本研究评估了她们的麻醉管理情况,并报告了分娩住院期间的麻醉并发症。
这是一项对接受阴道分娩或剖宫产的ACM-Ⅰ患者进行的多中心、回顾性队列研究。数据来自美国四个学术机构的电子数据库,其中三个机构使用2007 - 2017年的国际疾病分类(ICD)编码,一个机构使用2004 - 2017年的编码。主要结局是麻醉并发症。
对148例患者的185次分娩数据进行了分析。147例(80%)病例在分娩前确诊为ACM-Ⅰ。53例(36%)患者在分娩前接受了神经外科会诊以管理ACM-Ⅰ。89例(48%)分娩记录了既往症状。80例(43%)为阴道分娩,其中62名女性(78%)接受了椎管内分娩镇痛。105例(57%)为剖宫产,其中70名女性(67%)接受了椎管内麻醉,34名(32%)接受了全身麻醉。3例(2%)接受椎管内麻醉的患者报告发生了硬膜穿刺后头痛,2例(12%)患有脊髓空洞症的患者也出现了该症状。有1例(3%)报告的全身麻醉病例发生了误吸性肺炎。
研究结果表明,无论麻醉管理方式如何,ACM-Ⅰ患者发生麻醉并发症的情况并不常见。尽管麻醉和产科护理的机构偏好似乎影响着患者管理,但研究结果表明,个体化方法在这一人群中具有良好的结局。