Posnick Jeffrey C, Kinard Brian E
Director, Posnick Center for Facial Plastic Surgery, Chevy Chase, MD; Clinical Professor of Surgery and Pediatrics, Georgetown University, Washington, DC; Clinical Professor of Orthodontics, University of Maryland School of Dentistry, Baltimore, MD; and Adjunct Professor of Oral and Maxillofacial Surgery, Howard College of Dentistry, Washington, DC.
Fellow, Posnick Center for Facial Plastic Surgery, Chevy Chase, MD.
J Oral Maxillofac Surg. 2019 Feb;77(2):408.e1-408.e10. doi: 10.1016/j.joms.2018.10.005. Epub 2018 Oct 16.
Crowdsourcing is increasingly being used in medical research to obtain the opinion and perception of laypeople. We hypothesized that a layperson's perception of a patient with long face dentofacial deformity is more favorable after orthognathic surgery than before surgery regarding perceived personality traits and emotional facial expressions.
We implemented a survey, distributed through Amazon.com's Mechanical Turk crowdsourcing platform, to compare 6 perceived personality traits and 6 perceived emotional traits before and after (>6 months) orthognathic surgery in patients through standardized photographs (3 facial views). The sample was composed of 20 patients randomly selected from our long face dentofacial deformity database, treated by 1 surgeon, all having undergone bimaxillary and chin orthognathic surgery. The outcome variable was change in each of the 12 perceived personality and emotional traits studied. Descriptive and bivariate statistics were computed. P < .05 was considered significant.
A total of 500 respondents (raters) completed the survey in less than 10 hours. The respondents were mostly men (60%), aged 25 to 34 years (57%), white (71%), and college graduates (53%) with an annual income between $20,000 and $50,000 (48%). After jaw reconstruction and completion of orthodontic treatment, long face patients as a group were perceived to be significantly more trustworthy, more friendly, more intelligent, more attractive, and more dominant and also perceived as happier and less angry, sad, afraid, or disgusted than they were before surgery (P < .05).
We confirmed that laypersons consistently report positive changes in a long face patient's perceived personality traits and perceived emotional expressions after bimaxillary and chin orthognathic surgery.
众包在医学研究中越来越多地被用于获取外行人员的意见和看法。我们假设,在外行人看来,正颌手术后长脸牙颌面畸形患者在个性特征和面部表情方面比手术前更具好感。
我们通过亚马逊公司的Mechanical Turk众包平台开展了一项调查,通过标准化照片(3个面部视图)比较正颌手术前后(>6个月)患者的6种可感知个性特征和6种可感知情绪特征。样本由从我们的长脸牙颌面畸形数据库中随机选取的20例患者组成,均由1名外科医生治疗,所有患者均接受了双颌和颏部正颌手术。研究的结果变量是所研究的12种可感知个性和情绪特征各自的变化情况。计算了描述性和双变量统计数据。P < 0.05被视为具有统计学意义。
共有500名受访者(评分者)在不到10小时内完成了调查。受访者大多为男性(60%),年龄在25至34岁之间(57%),白人(71%),大学毕业生(53%),年收入在20,000美元至50,000美元之间(48%)。在颌骨重建和正畸治疗完成后,作为一个群体的长脸患者被认为比手术前明显更值得信赖、更友好、更聪明、更有吸引力、更具主导性,并且也被认为更快乐,愤怒、悲伤、恐惧或厌恶的程度更低(P < 0.05)。
我们证实,在外行人看来,双颌和颏部正颌手术后长脸患者的可感知个性特征和可感知情绪表达持续出现积极变化。