Gordon K D
Department of Anthropology, National Museum of Natural History, Smithsonian Institution, Washington DC 20560.
Scanning Microsc. 1988 Jun;2(2):1139-47.
Dental microwear analysis is a method of inferring oral events (primarily food processing and aspects of masticatory biomechanics) from microscopic abrasion patterns retained on the enamel surfaces of teeth. Although some qualitative pattern differences may be easily distinguishable, most of the significant results produced thus far have derived from quantified studies of SEM images of occlusal enamel. It often goes unnoticed by readers of microwear reports who are not themselves specialists that microwear analysis is essentially a statistical method, not a visual one. In this review of current techniques and methods, several problems in current approaches are detailed. It is noted that feature definition can have significant effects on ultimate pattern differentiation. Sampling bias is also a major concern, as most microwear studies are carried out on samples which are very small. Compounding this are the effects of magnification level choices, and the effects of SEM instrumentation on feature visibility. Finally, the interpretation of pattern differences requires careful attention to comparisons of within-group and between-group variability.
牙齿微磨损分析是一种从牙齿釉质表面留存的微观磨损模式推断口腔事件(主要是食物加工和咀嚼生物力学方面)的方法。虽然一些定性的模式差异可能很容易区分,但迄今为止产生的大多数重要结果都来自对咬合面釉质扫描电子显微镜(SEM)图像的量化研究。对于微磨损报告的读者(他们本身并非专家)来说,常常没有注意到微磨损分析本质上是一种统计方法,而非视觉方法。在对当前技术和方法的这篇综述中,详细阐述了当前方法中存在的几个问题。值得注意的是,特征定义可能对最终的模式区分产生重大影响。抽样偏差也是一个主要问题,因为大多数微磨损研究是在非常小的样本上进行的。放大倍数水平选择的影响以及SEM仪器对特征可见性的影响使问题更加复杂。最后,对模式差异的解释需要仔细关注组内和组间变异性的比较。