Courtet P, Olié E
Département d'urgence et post-urgence psychiatrique, université Montpellier, CHU de Montpellier, 371, avenue du Doyen-Gaston-Giraud, 34295 Montpellier cedex 5, France.
Département d'urgence et post-urgence psychiatrique, université Montpellier, CHU de Montpellier, 371, avenue du Doyen-Gaston-Giraud, 34295 Montpellier cedex 5, France.
Encephale. 2019 Jan;45 Suppl 1:S7-S12. doi: 10.1016/j.encep.2018.09.005. Epub 2018 Nov 11.
Intolerable pain is often reported in suicide notes. Moreover, the frequency of life events preceding a suicidal act is high, especially interpersonal difficulties. Such adversity is the source of psychological or social pain.
We propose a narrative review to discuss the role of pain in the suicidal process while having a focus on social ties.
Using Ecological Momentary Assessment in suicide attempters it has been shown that being alone increased suicidal ideation while being with close others significantly reduced this risk. At a neuroanatomical level, suicidal vulnerability is associated with dysfunctional insula activation during social exclusion, a region involved in social and physical pain processing. Social pain elicited by social exclusion or devaluation shares common neurobiological patterns with physical pain. It is also an exemplar of psychological pain. Despite the complexity of its definition, higher psychological pain levels are associated with suicidal ideation and acts. Finally, intense physical pain or chronic pain are strong risk factors of suicidal ideation and act. Interestingly, suicide notes often report the existence of an intolerable pain. Presence of psychological pain and difficulties in communication predict the lethality and seriousness of suicide attempts. Moreover, presence of psychological pain is associated with more impulsive choices in suicidal patients, suggesting that a suicidal act is a means to escape intolerable suffering despite negative long-term consequences (i.e. death). Analgesics are usually used to get relief from pain but are also frequently involved in suicidal overdoses. It has been shown that opioid analgesics are associated with an increased risk of suicide. Higher consumption of opioid analgesics has been shown in suicidal patients in comparison to patients with history of depression but no suicidal act and healthy controls whereas non-suicidal patients were those reporting higher presence of pain in comparison to healthy controls. It may suggest that opioids are being used by suicidal patients to get relief from psychological/social pain rather than from physical pain. Involvement of opioidergic system in suicidal process opens new therapeutic strategies. Recently, the time-limited, short-term use of very low dosages of sublingual buprenorphine (vs. placebo) was associated with decreased suicidal ideation and mental pain in severely suicidal patients without substance abuse. In a randomized controlled trial comparing a 7-week acceptance and commitment therapy (ACT) versus relaxation group, as adjunct to treatment as usual for adult outpatients suffering from a current suicidal behavior disorder, ACT has shown its effectiveness in reducing suicidal ideation and psychological pain. Evidence indicates that maintaining contact either via letter, postcard or telephone with at-risk adults following discharge from care services after a suicide attempt can reduce reattempt risk. Based on these results, a preventive program of recontact for suicide attempters, VIGILANS, has been developed in France in usual care.
The approach of the suicidal issue by the angle of pain and social disconnection offers new advances to improve clinical assessment, to identify new biological pathways involved in suicidal risk, and to propose innovative therapeutic and preventive actions.
自杀遗书常提及难以忍受的痛苦。此外,自杀行为发生前生活事件的频率较高,尤其是人际困难。这种逆境是心理或社会痛苦的根源。
我们进行一项叙述性综述,以探讨痛苦在自杀过程中的作用,同时关注社会关系。
对自杀未遂者采用生态瞬时评估表明,独处会增加自杀意念,而与亲密他人在一起则显著降低这种风险。在神经解剖学层面,自杀易感性与社会排斥期间脑岛激活功能失调有关,脑岛是一个参与社会和身体疼痛处理的区域。社会排斥或贬低引发的社会痛苦与身体疼痛具有共同的神经生物学模式。它也是心理痛苦的一个范例。尽管其定义复杂,但较高的心理痛苦水平与自杀意念和行为相关。最后,剧烈的身体疼痛或慢性疼痛是自杀意念和行为的强烈危险因素。有趣的是,自杀遗书常常报告存在难以忍受的痛苦。心理痛苦的存在和沟通困难可预测自杀未遂的致死性和严重性。此外,心理痛苦的存在与自杀患者更冲动的选择相关,这表明自杀行为是一种逃避难以忍受的痛苦的手段,尽管会带来负面的长期后果(即死亡)。镇痛药通常用于缓解疼痛,但也经常与自杀性过量用药有关。研究表明,阿片类镇痛药与自杀风险增加有关。与有抑郁症病史但无自杀行为的患者及健康对照相比,自杀患者中阿片类镇痛药的消费量更高,而非自杀患者与健康对照相比报告疼痛存在的比例更高。这可能表明自杀患者使用阿片类药物是为了缓解心理/社会痛苦而非身体疼痛。阿片能系统参与自杀过程为新的治疗策略开辟了道路。最近,在无药物滥用的严重自杀患者中,短期使用极低剂量的舌下丁丙诺啡(与安慰剂相比)与自杀意念和精神痛苦的减少有关。在一项随机对照试验中,将为期7周的接受与承诺疗法(ACT)与放松组进行比较,作为对目前有自杀行为障碍的成年门诊患者常规治疗的辅助手段,ACT已显示出在降低自杀意念和心理痛苦方面的有效性。有证据表明,在自杀未遂者从护理服务机构出院后,通过信件、明信片或电话与有风险的成年人保持联系可降低再次尝试的风险。基于这些结果,法国在常规护理中为自杀未遂者制定了一项重新联系预防计划,即VIGILANS。
从痛苦和社会脱节的角度探讨自杀问题为改善临床评估、识别自杀风险中涉及的新生物学途径以及提出创新的治疗和预防措施提供了新进展。