School of Environment, Tsinghua University, Beijing, 100084, China.
Department of Engineering, University of Cambridge, Cambridge, CB2 1PZ, United Kingdom.
Environ Pollut. 2019 Feb;245:363-370. doi: 10.1016/j.envpol.2018.11.011. Epub 2018 Nov 12.
Lead contamination is widespread across China, posing a serious public health concern. In quantifying child lead exposure, established health risk assessment (HRA) approaches often take into account residential soil lead levels. However, this may not constitute a significant exposure source for children in urban mainland China, where the population mainly dwell in high-rise buildings without back or front yards. In this setting, children's playgrounds may represent a more probable exposure source. The present study analyzed lead levels in settled dust on playground equipment and in surficial soils at 71 playgrounds in Beijing, China. Our results reveal that the average playground dust lead concentration was 80.5 mg/kg, more than twice the average soil lead concentration of 36.2 mg/kg. It was found that there are differences in statistical and spatial distributions for lead in playground dust and soils. Lead levels in equipment dust were largely consistent across Beijing, with elevated levels detected at locations in the main city area, the newly developed Tongzhou District, and the rural counties. Whereas average soil lead concentrations were higher at playgrounds in the main city area than other areas of Beijing. Statistical analysis suggests that the lead content in dust and soil may derive from different natural and anthropogenic sources. Equipment dust lead may be associated with long-distance atmospheric transportation and deposition. Whereas lead in soil is more likely to be associated with local traffic. This study also found that, in certain areas of Beijing, the risk of blood lead levels (BLLs) exceeding safe levels was up to 6 times higher when based on dust exposure than when based on playground soil exposure. The results of this study suggests that HRA undertaken for children in urban mainland China should pay closer attention to children's playgrounds as a lead exposure source, and, in particular, playground equipment dust.
中国各地普遍存在铅污染,对公共健康构成严重威胁。在量化儿童铅暴露水平时,已建立的健康风险评估(HRA)方法通常会考虑住宅土壤中的铅含量。然而,对于中国大陆的城市儿童来说,这可能不是一个主要的暴露源,因为这些地区的人口主要居住在没有后院或前院的高层建筑中。在这种情况下,儿童游乐场可能是一个更有可能的暴露源。本研究分析了中国北京市 71 个游乐场设备上的积尘和表层土壤中的铅含量。研究结果表明,平均游乐场积尘中的铅浓度为 80.5mg/kg,是平均土壤铅浓度 36.2mg/kg 的两倍多。研究发现,游乐场积尘和土壤中的铅含量在统计和空间分布上存在差异。设备积尘中的铅含量在北京市范围内基本一致,在市中心、新开发的通州区和农村县的部分地区发现了较高的浓度。而在市中心地区的游乐场中,土壤中的平均铅浓度高于北京市其他地区。统计分析表明,积尘和土壤中的铅含量可能来自不同的自然和人为来源。设备积尘中的铅可能与长距离大气传输和沉降有关。而土壤中的铅可能与当地交通有关。本研究还发现,在北京市的某些地区,基于积尘暴露,儿童血铅水平(BLLs)超过安全水平的风险比基于土壤暴露的风险高出 6 倍。本研究结果表明,在中国城市地区进行儿童 HRA 时,应更加关注儿童游乐场作为铅暴露源,特别是游乐场设备积尘。