Department of Regulatory Physiology, University of Dokkyo School of Medicine.
Department of Physical Therapy, Aoi Medical Academy.
Magn Reson Med Sci. 2019 Jul 16;18(3):184-193. doi: 10.2463/mrms.mp.2018-0059. Epub 2018 Nov 19.
In order to detect exercised muscles by the increase in T, we have defined a Gaussian T distribution and reference values (T and SD) in resting state muscles, and a threshold for detecting exercised muscles.
The subjects were healthy adult volunteers (14 males and 12 females). Multiple-spin-echo (MSE) MR images were obtained with 10 TE values from 10 to 100 ms using a 0.2T MRI system. T values for 10 forearm muscles were obtained in the resting state and after isometric wrist flexion exercise with 5%, 15%, and 25% of the maximum voluntary contraction (MVC). Z values were obtained by (T - T)/SD, where T was T after exercise. Based on sample size calculations, three thresholds (Z = 1.00, 2.56, and 3.07) were applied to agonist and antagonist muscles.
A normal distribution of T was detected in resting muscles at 34 ± 3 ms (mean ± standard deviation [SD]) in 26 subjects using the Kolmogorov-Smirnov test, the Shapiro-Wilk test, and the Jarque-Bera test (P > 0.05). No gender differences were shown between the T or SD, and a similar result was obtained in 12 measurements on a single subject (P < 0.01). The T and SD were used for reference values. The threshold Z = 1.00 showed the highest sensitivity (0.86) even with 5% MVC, but it showed a lower specificity (0.85) than the other thresholds. Z = 3.07 showed the highest specificity (1.0), but it showed a lower sensitivity (0.36) with the 5% MVC, compared with Z = 2.56 (0.50). The receiver operating characteristics analysis also supported these results.
We found that the T distribution in muscles was Gaussian, suggesting that a one-sample t-test can be applied, and that Z = 2.56 could cover low-intensity exercise with high specificity and a low false-positive rate.
为了通过 T 的增加来检测运动肌肉,我们定义了一个高斯 T 分布和静息状态肌肉的参考值(T 和 SD),以及检测运动肌肉的阈值。
研究对象为健康成年志愿者(14 名男性和 12 名女性)。使用 0.2T MRI 系统,从 10 到 100ms 获得 10 个 TE 值的多自旋回波(MSE)MR 图像。在静息状态和等长腕屈肌运动后,用 5%、15%和 25%的最大自主收缩(MVC)获得 10 块前臂肌肉的 T 值。Z 值通过(T-T)/SD 获得,其中 T 为运动后的 T 值。基于样本量计算,在 26 名受试者中,使用三个阈值(Z=1.00、2.56 和 3.07)应用于拮抗剂和拮抗剂肌肉。
使用 Kolmogorov-Smirnov 检验、Shapiro-Wilk 检验和 Jarque-Bera 检验(P>0.05),在 26 名受试者的静息肌肉中检测到 T 的正态分布,在 34±3ms。在性别方面,T 或 SD 之间没有差异,在一名受试者的 12 次测量中也得到了类似的结果(P<0.01)。T 和 SD 用于参考值。阈值 Z=1.00 即使在 5%MVC 时也显示出最高的灵敏度(0.86),但与其他阈值相比,特异性(0.85)较低。Z=3.07 的特异性最高(1.0),但与 Z=2.56(0.50)相比,在 5%MVC 时灵敏度较低(0.36)。接收器操作特征分析也支持这些结果。
我们发现肌肉中的 T 分布呈高斯分布,这表明可以应用单样本 t 检验,并且 Z=2.56 可以以高特异性和低假阳性率覆盖低强度运动。