Department of Communicative Disorders and Deaf Education, Utah State University, Logan.
Lang Speech Hear Serv Sch. 2019 Jan 28;50(1):53-70. doi: 10.1044/2018_LSHSS-18-0047.
Purpose This preliminary study investigated an intervention procedure employing 2 types of note-taking and oral practice to improve expository reporting skills. Procedure Forty-four 4th to 6th graders with language-related learning disabilities from 9 schools were assigned to treatment or control conditions that were balanced for grade, oral language, and other features. The treatment condition received 6 30-min individual or pair sessions from the school of speech-language pathologists (SLPs). Treatment involved reducing statements from grade-level science articles into concise ideas, recording the ideas as pictographic and conventional notes, and expanding from the notes into full oral sentences that are then combined into oral reports. Participants were pretested and posttested on taking notes from grade-level history articles and using the notes to give oral reports. Posttesting also included written reports 1 to 3 days following the oral reports. Results The treatment group showed significantly greater improvement than the control group on multiple quality features of the notes and oral reports. Quantity, holistic oral quality, and delayed written reports were not significantly better. The SLPs reported high levels of student engagement and learning of skills and content within treatment. They attributed the perceived benefits to the elements of simplicity, visuals, oral practice, repeated opportunities, and visible progress. Conclusion This study indicates potential for Sketch and Speak to improve student performance in expository reporting and gives direction for strengthening and further investigating this novel SLP treatment. Supplemental Material https://doi.org/10.23641/asha.7268651.
目的 本初步研究调查了一种干预程序,该程序采用了两种记笔记和口语练习的方法,以提高说明文报告技能。
过程 9 所学校的 44 名 4 至 6 年级有语言相关学习障碍的学生被分配到治疗组或对照组,这些组在年级、口语和其他特征方面是平衡的。治疗组接受了来自言语语言病理学家(SLP)学校的 6 次 30 分钟的个体或小组治疗。治疗包括将年级水平的科学文章中的陈述减少为简洁的想法,将这些想法记录为图像和传统笔记,并从笔记扩展为完整的口头句子,然后将这些句子组合成口头报告。参与者在记录来自年级水平的历史文章的笔记和使用笔记进行口头报告方面进行了前测和后测。后测还包括口头报告后 1 至 3 天的书面报告。
结果 治疗组在笔记和口头报告的多个质量特征上的表现明显优于对照组。数量、整体口头质量和延迟书面报告没有明显提高。SLP 报告了学生在治疗过程中的高度参与和技能及内容的学习。他们将这种感知到的益处归因于简单性、视觉效果、口语练习、重复机会和可见的进展等因素。
结论 本研究表明,Sketch and Speak 有可能提高学生在说明文报告方面的表现,并为加强和进一步研究这种新的 SLP 治疗方法提供了方向。