Himida Tarek, Nanjappa Sucharita, Yuan Siyang, Freeman Ruth
Dental Health Services Research Unit, School of Dentistry, University of Dundee, Dundee, UK.
Eur J Dent Educ. 2019 May;23(2):95-100. doi: 10.1111/eje.12407. Epub 2018 Dec 7.
Communication skills are an integral component of dental undergraduate education. Due to the complex nature of these skills, didactic teaching methods used in other educational contexts can be limited. Interactive and participative methods rooted in modern adult learning theories, such as Forum Theatre, may be more effective in the teaching of communication skills.
To explore the usefulness of Forum Theatre in teaching clinical undergraduate dental students how to break bad news to their patients.
A purposive sample of 4th-year undergraduate dental students was invited to participate. An evaluation questionnaire was given to the students and collected after the Forum Theatre interactive session. Participants were asked to provide self-reported accounts on the most and least useful parts of the session, as well as the most important learning outcome. Usefulness of the session in clinical work, increasing confidence and ability in breaking bad news, were evaluated via a 5-point Likert-scale type question. Qualitative data were analysed using Framework Analysis to explore the themes found in the open-text component. Descriptive statistics were used to analyse the Likert-scale items.
One hundred and fifteen completed questionnaires were collected from the 2015 and 2016 classes. Most students gave the Forum Theatre session a rating of 3 or above on a 5-point Likert scale; indicating that they found it useful. Qualitative results also showed that most participants liked the teaching session thanks to its interactive nature, the use of actors and the input of the facilitators. The majority of students showed preference towards smaller groups which give everyone equal opportunity to participate without unnecessary repetition.
The results seem to confirm previous findings. Students rated their learning experience involving Forum Theatre favourably. Smaller groups and trained facilitators are required for the success of this teaching method. Further research is needed to assess the long-term educational benefits of Forum Theatre.
沟通技巧是牙科本科教育不可或缺的组成部分。由于这些技能的复杂性,其他教育背景下使用的讲授式教学方法可能存在局限性。植根于现代成人学习理论的互动式和参与式方法,如论坛剧场,可能在沟通技巧教学中更有效。
探讨论坛剧场在教导牙科临床本科学生如何向患者传达坏消息方面的实用性。
邀请了一个由四年级牙科本科学生组成的有目的样本参与。在论坛剧场互动环节结束后,向学生发放并收集了一份评估问卷。参与者被要求就该环节最有用和最没用的部分以及最重要的学习成果提供自我报告。通过一个5点李克特量表式问题评估该环节在临床工作中的实用性、在传达坏消息方面增强的信心和能力。使用框架分析法分析定性数据,以探索在开放式文本部分中发现的主题。使用描述性统计分析李克特量表项目。
从2015级和2016级学生中收集到115份完整问卷。大多数学生在5点李克特量表上给论坛剧场环节的评分在3分及以上;表明他们认为该环节有用。定性结果还显示,大多数参与者喜欢该教学环节,因为其具有互动性、使用了演员以及有主持人的参与。大多数学生倾向于规模较小的小组,这样能让每个人都有平等的参与机会且不会有不必要的重复。
结果似乎证实了先前的研究发现。学生对涉及论坛剧场的学习体验评价良好。这种教学方法的成功实施需要规模较小的小组和经过培训的主持人。需要进一步研究来评估论坛剧场的长期教育效益。