Ayalon Liat
Louis and Gabi Weisfeld School of Social Work, Bar Ilan University, Ramat Gan, Israel.
Innov Aging. 2018 Jul 27;2(2):igy021. doi: 10.1093/geroni/igy021. eCollection 2018 Jun.
The present study compares how 2 settings: adult day care centers (ADCCs) and continuing care retirement communities (CCRCs) fare with regard to loneliness and anxiety about aging. Loneliness is a highly prevalent and distressing subjective experience of inadequate social relations, which has negative effects on health and well-being. Anxiety about aging is defined as worries brought up by imagining the negative consequences and losses associated with old age. The study also examines whether anxiety about aging accounts for differences in loneliness between the 2 settings. This study took place in Israel, where ADCCs are funded by the National Insurance Institute of Israel and CCRCs tend to be funded by private income and wealth. Despite notable differences between the settings, a common goal of both is to reduce loneliness among older adults.
A cross-sectional design of 4 ADCCs and 4 CCRCs ( = 456).
Compared with CCRC residents, older adults in ADCCs reported higher levels of loneliness (Mean [] = 1.46 [0.60], Mean [] = 1.78 [0.80], respectively, [df]= -5.10 [448], < .001) and higher levels of anxiety about aging (Mean [] = 2.96 [0.88], Mean [] = 3.27 [0.99], respectively, [df] = -3.42 [440], < .001). Anxiety about aging partially accounted for the differences between the 2 settings in levels of loneliness ( = 0.03, 95% confidence interval [CI]: 0.0037-0.0651).
Although it is not possible to determine causality from this cross-sectional design, it is possible that CCRCs provide a better social outlet for older adults than ADCCs.
本研究比较了两种环境——成人日托中心(ADCCs)和持续照料退休社区(CCRCs)——在孤独感和对衰老的焦虑方面的情况。孤独感是社交关系不足的一种极为普遍且令人苦恼的主观体验,对健康和幸福有着负面影响。对衰老的焦虑被定义为因想象与老年相关的负面后果和损失而产生的担忧。该研究还考察了对衰老的焦虑是否能解释这两种环境中孤独感的差异。本研究在以色列开展,在那里成人日托中心由以色列国家保险协会提供资金,而持续照料退休社区往往由私人收入和财富提供资金。尽管这两种环境存在显著差异,但它们的一个共同目标都是减少老年人的孤独感。
对4个成人日托中心和4个持续照料退休社区进行横断面设计(n = 456)。
与持续照料退休社区的居民相比,成人日托中心的老年人报告的孤独感水平更高(平均[M]分别为1.46[0.60]和1.78[0.80],t[自由度df]= -5.10[448],p <.001),对衰老的焦虑水平也更高(平均[M]分别为2.96[0.88]和3.27[0.99],t[自由度df]= -3.42[440],p <.001)。对衰老的焦虑部分解释了这两种环境在孤独感水平上的差异(β = 0.03,95%置信区间[CI]:0.0037 - 0.0651)。
尽管从这个横断面设计无法确定因果关系,但持续照料退休社区可能比成人日托中心为老年人提供了更好的社交途径。