Vorontsov N N
Genetika. 1988 Jun;24(6):1081-8.
A brief survey of the development of concepts on the role of macromutations in evolution is given. Contrary to Iu. A. Filipchenko (1926, 1927), who introduced the "micro- and macromutation" terms and believed that regularities of macroevolution could not be reduced to microevolutionary processes, the majority of "synthetists" explained any form of evolution by changes in allele frequencies. From the studies of Drosophila homoeotic mutants R. Goldschmidt (1940) developed the concept of "hopeful monsters" and their role in macroevolution. However, the homoeotic mutants are of drastically reduced viability, which allows the gradualists to reject Goldschmidt's ideas. The distribution of hairlessness mutations (hairless, nude etc.) with the monogenic pattern of inheritance in mammals was studied. Hairless mutants are known in Peromyscus, Mus musculus, Rattus rattus, R. norvegicus, Canis familiaris, Ovis aries. Hairlessness as norm is found in 53 among contemporaneous 1037 mammalian genera. Part of these cases (hairlessness in all Cetacea and Sirenia) may be explained in terms of both macromutations and obligatory gradualism. There is no doubt as to the macromutational origin of hairlessness in the bat Cheiromeles and the rodent Heterocephalus (Bathyergidae); the genera systematically and ecologically close to these have normal pelage. It is quite possible that hairlessness of walrus (Odobenus) has the same origin. The appearance and fixation of single Goldschmidt's macromutation cannot yet be considered as a macroevolutionary process, though the possibility of fixation of a macromutation in nature as a species and genus character contradicts strongly the concept of obligatory gradualism of evolution.
本文简要综述了有关大突变在进化中作用的概念发展。与引入“微突变和大突变”术语并认为宏观进化规律不能归结为微观进化过程的尤·阿·菲利琴科(1926年、1927年)相反,大多数“综合论者”用等位基因频率的变化来解释任何形式的进化。通过对果蝇同源异型突变体的研究,R. 戈德施密特(1940年)提出了“有希望的怪物”的概念及其在宏观进化中的作用。然而,同源异型突变体的生存能力大幅降低,这使得渐变论者能够摒弃戈德施密特的观点。对哺乳动物中具有单基因遗传模式的无毛突变(无毛、裸等)分布进行了研究。在鹿鼠、小家鼠、黑家鼠、褐家鼠、家犬、绵羊中都发现了无毛突变体。在1037个现存哺乳动物属中,有53个属存在无毛现象。其中部分情况(所有鲸目动物和海牛目的无毛现象)既可以用大突变来解释,也可以用必然的渐变论来解释。毫无疑问,蝙蝠的皱唇蝠属和啮齿动物的裸鼹鼠属(滨鼠科)的无毛现象起源于大突变;与它们系统发育和生态上相近的属具有正常的皮毛。海象(海象属)的无毛现象很可能也有相同的起源。虽然一个大突变在自然界中作为物种和属的特征固定下来的可能性与进化的必然渐变论概念强烈相悖,但单个戈德施密特大突变的出现和固定尚不能被视为一个宏观进化过程。