Green Jacqueline, Rasmussen Kari
Educational Research and Scholarship Unit, School of Dentistry, Faculty of Medicine and Dentistry, University of Alberta, Alberta, Canada.
Can Med Educ J. 2018 Nov 12;9(4):e102-e110. eCollection 2018 Nov.
In each discipline, there are moments where students "get stuck" in their education and/or training and are often unable to move forward. These moments may be caused by threshold concepts as they represent a portal that students must cross in order to become successful in their chosen profession. This study investigated the threshold concepts from the instructors' perspective that students must navigate as they transform from learners to dentists within a dental program.
Two focus groups with faculty members within the School of Dentistry, University of Alberta were completed in the fall of 2017. Focus groups explored the faculty's perception of the students' transition from learner to dentist, difficult moments in the program, and the students' ability to navigate the program successfully.
A qualitative phenomenographic analysis of the faculty focus group transcripts identified four potential threshold concepts within the dental program: 1) dealing with the whole patient, 2) accountability, 3) that you may not know everything, and 4) problem solving and adapting during practice.
This study demonstrates that there are concepts within a dental program that faculty believe students must navigate in order to transition from learner to dentist. These concepts may inform curriculum design as well as other disciplines in the health sciences.
在各个学科中,学生在其教育和/或培训过程中都会遇到“瓶颈”,往往无法取得进展。这些时刻可能是由阈值概念引起的,因为它们代表着学生为了在所选职业中取得成功而必须跨越的一个门槛。本研究从教师的角度调查了学生在牙科课程中从学习者转变为牙医过程中必须跨越的阈值概念。
2017年秋季,在阿尔伯塔大学牙科学院与教师进行了两个焦点小组讨论。焦点小组探讨了教师对学生从学习者向牙医转变的看法、课程中的困难时刻以及学生成功完成课程的能力。
对教师焦点小组记录进行的定性现象学分析确定了牙科课程中的四个潜在阈值概念:1)处理整个患者的问题,2)问责制,3)你可能并非无所不知,4)在实践中解决问题和适应变化。
本研究表明,牙科课程中有一些概念,教师认为学生必须跨越这些概念才能从学习者转变为牙医。这些概念可能为课程设计以及健康科学的其他学科提供参考。