Africa Health Research Institute, Durban, South Africa.
Faculty of Epidemiology and Population Health, London School of Hygiene & Tropical Medicine, London, United Kingdom.
PLoS One. 2018 Dec 13;13(12):e0208243. doi: 10.1371/journal.pone.0208243. eCollection 2018.
BACKGROUND: The 'DREAMS Partnership' promotes a multi-sectoral approach to reduce adolescent girls and young women's (AGYW) vulnerability through a core package of interventions targeting multiple sources of HIV risk-to promote Determined, Resilient, Empowered, AIDS-free, Mentored and Safe (DREAMS) lives. Implementation of such multi-sectoral programmes is complex and requires adaptation to national and local contexts. We describe the early implementation of DREAMS in diverse settings, to identify lessons for the scale-up and replication of combination programmes for young people. METHODS: As part of evaluations underway in six DREAMS sites in three countries (Kenya, South Africa and Zimbabwe), we draw on process evaluation data collected from focus group discussions, key informant interviews, and in-depth interviews with beneficiaries, parents/caregivers, programme managers and opinion leaders. Additionally, structured observations were conducted and Gantt charts completed upon consultation with implementers. We concurrently reviewed documentation available on DREAMS and held cross-site discussions to interpret findings. FINDINGS: All sites sought to implement all components of the DREAMS core package, but how and when they were implemented varied by context. Models of delivery differed, with either multiple or single partners responsible for some or all interventions. Key challenges included the urgent and ambitious expectations of DREAMS; 'layering' multiple interventions across different sectors (health, education, social welfare); supporting individuals' journeys between services to improve uptake and retention; engaging communities beyond direct beneficiaries; avoiding perceived/actual exclusivity; and ensuring continuity of commitment and funding for DREAMS. Despite significant challenges, DREAMS was well-received in the communities and perceived by both beneficiaries and implementers to empower AGYW to remain HIV negative. Structures, protocols and tools were introduced to strengthen referrals and deliver services targeted to the age and circumstances of young people. CONCLUSIONS: The benefits of combinations or integrated 'packages' of interventions are increasingly recognised. Early implementation of DREAMS provides useful lessons for improving coordination across multiple partners using a phased, systematic approach, regular adaptions to each unique context, and ensuring community ownership.
背景:“DREAMS 伙伴关系”通过针对多种 HIV 风险源的核心干预措施,促进多部门方法,以减少少女和年轻妇女(AGYW)的脆弱性-促进有决心、有韧性、有能力、无艾滋病、有指导和安全(DREAMS)的生活。实施这种多部门方案很复杂,需要适应国家和地方情况。我们描述了 DREAMS 在不同环境中的早期实施情况,以确定为年轻人的综合方案的扩大和复制提供的经验教训。
方法:作为正在进行的六个 DREAMS 地点在三个国家(肯尼亚、南非和津巴布韦)评估的一部分,我们利用从焦点小组讨论、主要知情人访谈以及与受益者、父母/照顾者、方案管理人员和意见领袖进行的深入访谈中收集的过程评估数据。此外,在与实施者协商后,进行了结构化观察并完成了甘特图。我们同时审查了关于 DREAMS 的文件,并举行了跨地点讨论以解释调查结果。
发现:所有地点都试图实施 DREAMS 核心方案的所有组成部分,但实施方式和时间因背景而异。提供模式不同,一些或所有干预措施由多个或单个合作伙伴负责。主要挑战包括 DREAMS 的紧急和雄心勃勃的期望;在不同部门(卫生、教育、社会福利)“分层”实施多项干预措施;支持个人在服务之间的旅程,以提高接受度和保留率;使社区超越直接受益者;避免被认为/实际的排他性;并确保 DREAMS 的承诺和资金的连续性。尽管面临重大挑战,但 DREAMS 在社区中受到欢迎,受益者和实施者都认为它使 AGYW 有能力保持艾滋病毒阴性。为了加强针对年轻人的年龄和情况的转介和提供服务,引入了结构、协议和工具。
结论:组合或综合“一揽子”干预措施的好处越来越被认识到。DREAMS 的早期实施为通过分阶段、系统的方法改善多个合作伙伴之间的协调、对每个独特的情况进行定期调整以及确保社区所有权提供了有用的经验教训。
PLOS Glob Public Health. 2024-5-31
J Int AIDS Soc. 2015-2-26