Newland X, Boller M, Boller E
a Department of Veterinary Clinical Sciences , University of Melbourne , Werribee , Victoria , 3030 , Australia.
N Z Vet J. 2019 Mar;67(2):55-65. doi: 10.1080/00480169.2018.1559108. Epub 2019 Jan 15.
This thematic review examines the literature regarding the relationship between domestic violence (DV) and pet abuse (PA) particularly in the veterinary clinical and educational contexts. It examines the significance of this relationship for the veterinary profession including the veterinarian's role and associated legal and ethical obligations, and relevant current veterinary education standards, to identify future clinical and educational directions. Articles were sourced from online databases by searching the keywords without date restrictions. Overall, 70 articles were retrieved and reviewed. Pet abuse has been identified as a potential risk factor for DV, and DV perpetrators may harm or kill a pet to exert physical, psychological or emotional control over an intimate partner. Given that victims of DV often seek veterinary aid for their pets, veterinarians may act as frontline professionals in the recognition of the link between PA and DV. Veterinarians must assess individual cases for diagnostic indicators of non-accidental injury and consider demographic factors to identify suspected PA and DV. Despite existing legal and ethical obligations of the veterinarian relating to suspected PA and victims of DV, veterinarians have uncertainty and unpreparedness in addressing PA and DV in a clinical context. Many factors may contribute to the lack of veterinary intervention in suspected cases of PA and DV including concern for animal welfare, confusion about the reporting process and uncertainty in differentiating accidental versus non-accidental injuries in pets. Specific published guidelines regarding the recognition and reporting of PA and DV in the veterinary clinical context are required. Limited published evidence exists examining the implementation and success of veterinary training regarding the relationship between DV and PA. Ultimately, veterinary student education is needed to prepare veterinarians for their response to PA and DV in practice. Further research is required to examine the effects of the delivery of content regarding the link between PA and DV in the veterinary curriculum on veterinary student knowledge and attitudes.
本专题综述考察了有关家庭暴力(DV)与虐待宠物(PA)之间关系的文献,特别是在兽医临床和教育背景下。它探讨了这种关系对兽医行业的重要性,包括兽医的角色以及相关的法律和道德义务,以及当前相关的兽医教育标准,以确定未来的临床和教育方向。通过搜索关键词从在线数据库中获取文章,无日期限制。总体而言,共检索并审阅了70篇文章。虐待宠物已被确定为家庭暴力的一个潜在风险因素,家庭暴力实施者可能会伤害或杀死宠物,以对亲密伴侣施加身体、心理或情感上的控制。鉴于家庭暴力受害者经常为其宠物寻求兽医帮助,兽医可能会成为识别虐待宠物与家庭暴力之间联系的一线专业人员。兽医必须评估个别病例中是否存在非意外伤害诊断指标,并考虑人口统计学因素,以识别疑似虐待宠物和家庭暴力情况。尽管兽医对疑似虐待宠物和家庭暴力受害者负有现有的法律和道德义务,但在临床环境中应对虐待宠物和家庭暴力时,兽医仍存在不确定性和准备不足的情况。许多因素可能导致在疑似虐待宠物和家庭暴力案件中缺乏兽医干预,包括对动物福利的关注、对报告流程的困惑以及在区分宠物意外伤害与非意外伤害方面的不确定性。需要制定关于在兽医临床环境中识别和报告虐待宠物及家庭暴力的具体公开指南。关于兽医培训中虐待宠物与家庭暴力关系的实施情况和成效的已发表证据有限。最终,需要对兽医学生进行教育,使其在实践中为应对虐待宠物和家庭暴力做好准备。需要进一步研究,以考察在兽医课程中提供有关虐待宠物与家庭暴力之间联系的内容对兽医学生知识和态度的影响。