Mauch Chelsea E, Wycherley Thomas P, Laws Rachel A, Johnson Brittany J, Bell Lucinda K, Golley Rebecca K
Nutrition and Dietetics, College of Nursing and Health Sciences, Flinders University, Bedford Park, Australia.
School of Pharmacy and Medical Sciences, Division of Health Sciences, University of South Australia, Adelaide, Australia.
JMIR Mhealth Uhealth. 2018 Dec 21;6(12):e11867. doi: 10.2196/11867.
Modern families are facing conflicting demands on their time and resources, which may be at the detriment of child and family diet quality. Innovative nutrition interventions providing parents with behavioral support for the provision of healthy food could alleviate this issue. Mobile apps have the potential to deliver such interventions by providing practical behavioral support remotely, interactively, and in context.
This review aimed to identify and assess popular, commercially available food- and nutrition-related mobile apps that offer support for the provision of healthy family food by (1) describing app scope and characteristics, (2) assessing app quality, and (3) conducting a behavioral analysis of app content and features.
Searches in the Google Play Store and Apple App Store between August 2017 and November 2017 identified apps addressing the food provision process. Apps were included if they were applicable to parents or families, written in English, and with a user rating of ≥4 stars. Weight loss and diet monitoring apps and subscription apps with no free versions were excluded. App quality was assessed using the Mobile App Rating Scale (4 domains: engagement, functionality, aesthetics, and information). App content and features were extracted and behavior change techniques (BCTs) identified.
Of the 2881 apps screened, 1.77% (51/2881) were included for assessment, comprising 23 recipe and recipe manager apps, 12 meal planning apps, 10 shopping list apps, 4 family organizers, and 2 food choice apps. Half (n=26) of the apps functioned primarily through user data input. Food choice and family organizer apps scored highest for app quality (mean 3.5 [SD 0.6] out of 5), whereas most apps scored well for functionality and poorly for engagement. Common app features with the potential to support healthy food provision included meal planners (n=26), shopping lists (n=44), and the ability to share app content (n=48). Behavioral support features mapped to relatively few BCTs (mean 3.9 [SD 1.9] per app), with Adding objects to the environment present in all apps, and 65% (33/51) including Instruction on how to perform the behavior.
Recipe and recipe manager apps, meal planning apps, and family organizers with integrated meal planning and shopping lists scored well for functionality and incorporated behavioral support features that could be used to address barriers to healthy food provision, although features were focused on planning behaviors. Future apps should combine a range of features such as meal planners, shopping lists, simple recipes, reminders and prompts, and food ordering to reduce the burden of the food provision pathway and incorporate a range of BCTs to maximize behavior change potential. Researchers and developers should consider features and content that improve the engagement quality of such apps.
现代家庭在时间和资源上面临着相互冲突的需求,这可能会损害儿童和家庭的饮食质量。创新的营养干预措施为父母提供关于提供健康食品的行为支持,可能会缓解这一问题。移动应用程序有潜力通过远程、交互式且在实际情境中提供实用的行为支持来提供此类干预。
本综述旨在识别和评估流行的、可商业获取的与食品和营养相关的移动应用程序,这些应用程序通过(1)描述应用程序的范围和特征,(2)评估应用程序质量,以及(3)对应用程序的内容和功能进行行为分析,为提供健康的家庭食品提供支持。
在2017年8月至2017年11月期间在谷歌Play商店和苹果应用商店进行搜索,以识别涉及食品供应过程的应用程序。如果应用程序适用于父母或家庭、用英语编写且用户评分≥4星,则将其纳入。减肥和饮食监测应用程序以及没有免费版本的订阅应用程序被排除。使用移动应用程序评分量表(4个领域:参与度、功能、美学和信息)评估应用程序质量。提取应用程序的内容和功能,并识别行为改变技术(BCT)。
在筛选的2881个应用程序中,1.77%(51/2881)被纳入评估,包括23个食谱和食谱管理应用程序、12个膳食计划应用程序、10个购物清单应用程序、4个家庭组织者应用程序和2个食物选择应用程序。一半(n = 26)的应用程序主要通过用户数据输入来运行。食物选择和家庭组织者应用程序在应用程序质量方面得分最高(平均3.5[标准差0.6],满分5分),而大多数应用程序在功能方面得分较好,在参与度方面得分较差。有可能支持提供健康食品的常见应用程序功能包括膳食计划器(n = 26)、购物清单(n = 44)以及共享应用程序内容的能力(n = 48)。行为支持功能映射到相对较少的BCT(每个应用程序平均3.9[标准差1.9]),所有应用程序都有在环境中添加物品的功能,65%(33/51)的应用程序包括如何执行行为的指导。
食谱和食谱管理应用程序、膳食计划应用程序以及集成了膳食计划和购物清单的家庭组织者应用程序在功能方面得分较好,并纳入了可用于解决提供健康食品障碍的行为支持功能,尽管这些功能主要集中在计划行为上。未来的应用程序应结合一系列功能,如膳食计划器、购物清单、简单食谱、提醒和提示以及食品订购,以减轻食品供应路径的负担,并纳入一系列BCT以最大限度地发挥行为改变的潜力。研究人员和开发人员应考虑能够提高此类应用程序参与度质量的功能和内容。