Grover Sandeep, Sahoo Swapnajeet, Srinivas Balachander, Tripathi Adarsh, Avasthi Ajit
King Georges Medical University, Lucknow, Uttar Pradesh, India.
Department of Psychiatry, Post Graduate Institute of Medical Education and Research, Chandigarh, India.
Indian J Psychiatry. 2018 Oct-Dec;60(4):445-460. doi: 10.4103/psychiatry.IndianJPsychiatry_334_18.
The aim of this study is to assess the perception of the young psychiatrists (aged ≤45 years) about their training received during the postgraduate training period.
An online E-mail survey using Survey Monkey electronic platform evaluated the perception of 451 psychiatrists about their own perception of training received during the postgraduation period.
About two-third ( = 308; 68.3%) of the respondents reported that their overall training was 'good' or 'very good'. However, training was rated as poor/very poor in subspecialties of child and adolescent psychiatry and geriatric psychiatry by 26.2% and 26.9% of the participants, respectively. Exposure/training was rated as "poor/very poor" by more than one-fifth of the participants in areas of repetitive transcranial magnetic stimulation and deep brain stimulation (69.9%), rehabilitation psychiatry (47%), forensic psychiatry (45.5%), psychodynamics (40.5%), neuroimaging (38.1%), psychotherapy (34.8%), orientation to private practice (26.9%), statistics (34.1%), writing skills (24.4%), ethical principles of research (23.5%), women mental health (23.3%), psychosexual medicine (22.7%), and research methodology (21.5%). Regarding academic activities involving writing skills, although majority (72.5%) of the participants reported being involved in writing case reports and half (50.3%) reported involvement in writing original articles, but exposure to writing other types of article was quite low. Training in different types psychotherapies in the form of adequate exposure, carrying out and supervision to different types of psychotherapy was inadequate/low for psychodynamic psychotherapies, rational emotive therapy, dialectical behavior therapy, eclectic psychotherapy, and other kind of therapies. A high proportion of respondents reported having good competence in the administration of modified electroconvulsive therapy and making presentation in academic fora just after passing degree from their institutes and at the time of survey (current competence). When comparisons were done between the different groups of institutes, significant difference was noted across all aspects of training.
The present survey reflects that there is a variation in the psychiatry training in India. Accordingly, it can be said that there is a need to develop a model for competency-based training program at the level of the Indian Psychiatric Society in consonance with training regulatory bodies like the Medical Council of India, which can be implemented across the country to harmonize the training.
本研究旨在评估年轻精神科医生(年龄≤45岁)对其在研究生培训期间所接受培训的看法。
使用Survey Monkey电子平台进行在线电子邮件调查,评估了451名精神科医生对其毕业后所接受培训的看法。
约三分之二(n = 308;68.3%)的受访者表示他们的整体培训“良好”或“非常好”。然而,分别有26.2%和26.9%的参与者将儿童和青少年精神病学及老年精神病学亚专业的培训评为“差”/“非常差”。超过五分之一的参与者将重复经颅磁刺激和脑深部刺激(69.9%)、康复精神病学(47%)、法医精神病学(45.5%)、心理动力学(40.5%)、神经影像学(38.1%)、心理治疗(34.8%)、私人执业指导(26.9%)、统计学(34.1%)、写作技巧(24.4%)、研究伦理原则(23.5%)、女性心理健康(23.3%)、性心理医学(22.7%)和研究方法(21.5%)等领域的接触/培训评为“差/非常差”。关于涉及写作技巧的学术活动,尽管大多数(72.5%)参与者报告参与撰写病例报告,一半(50.3%)报告参与撰写原创文章,但接触撰写其他类型文章的机会相当少。对于心理动力学心理治疗、合理情绪疗法、辩证行为疗法、折衷心理治疗和其他类型的疗法,以充分接触、实施和监督不同类型心理治疗形式进行的不同类型心理治疗培训不足/水平较低。很大比例的受访者报告在刚从所在机构毕业时和调查时(当前能力)在改良电休克治疗的实施和在学术论坛上进行报告方面具有良好的能力。当在不同组别的机构之间进行比较时,在培训的各个方面都发现了显著差异。
本次调查反映出印度的精神科培训存在差异。因此,可以说有必要在印度精神病学会层面根据印度医学委员会等培训监管机构制定基于能力的培训计划模型,并在全国范围内实施以统一培训。