Wahlen Bianca M, El-Menyar Ayman, Asim Mohammad, Al-Thani Hassan
Department of Anesthesia, Hamad General Hospital, Doha, Qatar.
Clinical Research, Trauma & Vascular Surgery, Hamad General Hospital, Doha, Qatar.
World J Emerg Med. 2019;10(1):19-26. doi: 10.5847/wjem.j.1920-8642.2019.01.003.
We aimed to describe the current practice of emergency physicians and anaesthesiologists in the selection of drugs for rapid-sequence induction (RSI) among trauma patients.
A prospective survey audit was conducted based on a self-administered questionnaire among two intubating specialties. The preferred type and dose of hypnotics, opioids, and muscle relaxants used for RSI in trauma patients were sought in the questionnaire. Data were compared for the use of induction agent, opioid use and muscle relaxant among stable and unstable trauma patients by the intubating specialties.
A total of 102 participants were included; 47 were anaesthetists and 55 were emergency physicians. Propofol (74.5%) and Etomidate (50.0%) were the most frequently used induction agents. Significantly higher proportion of anesthesiologist used Propofol whereas, Etomidate was commonly used by emergency physicians in stable patients (=0.001). Emergency physicians preferred Etomidate (63.6%) and Ketamine (20.0%) in unstable patients. The two groups were comparable for opioid use for stable patients. In unstable patients, use of opioid differed significantly by intubating specialties. The relation between rocuronium and suxamethonium use did change among the anaesthetists. Emergency physicians used more suxamethonium (55.6% vs. 27.7%, =0.01) in stable as well as unstable (43.4 % vs. 27.7%, =0.08) patients.
There is variability in the use of drugs for RSI in trauma patients amongst emergency physicians and anaesthesiologists. There is a need to develop an RSI protocol using standardized types and dose of these agents to deliver an effective airway management for trauma patients.
我们旨在描述急诊医生和麻醉医生在为创伤患者选择快速顺序诱导(RSI)药物方面的当前做法。
基于一份自填式问卷,对两个插管专业进行了前瞻性调查审计。问卷中询问了用于创伤患者RSI的首选催眠药、阿片类药物和肌肉松弛剂的类型及剂量。通过插管专业比较了稳定和不稳定创伤患者诱导剂的使用、阿片类药物使用及肌肉松弛剂使用情况的数据。
共纳入102名参与者;47名是麻醉医生,55名是急诊医生。丙泊酚(74.5%)和依托咪酯(50.0%)是最常用的诱导剂。使用丙泊酚的麻醉医生比例显著更高,而依托咪酯在稳定患者中是急诊医生常用的药物(P = 0.001)。急诊医生在不稳定患者中更倾向于使用依托咪酯(63.6%)和氯胺酮(20.0%)。两组在稳定患者的阿片类药物使用方面具有可比性。在不稳定患者中,插管专业之间阿片类药物的使用差异显著。麻醉医生中罗库溴铵和琥珀胆碱的使用关系确实有所变化。急诊医生在稳定患者(55.6%对27.7%,P = 0.01)以及不稳定患者(43.4%对27.7%,P = 0.08)中使用琥珀胆碱更多。
急诊医生和麻醉医生在创伤患者RSI药物使用方面存在差异。需要制定一份使用这些药物标准化类型和剂量的RSI方案,以便为创伤患者提供有效的气道管理。