Hofer Sarah I, Schumacher Ralph, Rubin Herbert
1School of Education, Technische Universität München, Arcisstr. 21, 80333 Munich, Germany.
2MINT-Learning Center, ETH Zurich, Clausiusstrasse 59, CH-8092 Zurich, Switzerland.
Int J STEM Educ. 2017;4(1):18. doi: 10.1186/s40594-017-0080-5. Epub 2017 Sep 20.
Valid assessment of the understanding of Newton's mechanics is highly relevant to both physics classrooms and research. Several tests have been developed. What remains missing, however, is an efficient and fair test of conceptual understanding that is adapted to the content taught to secondary school students and that can be validly applied as a pre- and posttest to reflect change. In this paper, we describe the development and evaluation of the test of basic Mechanics Conceptual Understanding (bMCU), which was designed to meet these requirements.
In the context of test development, qualitative and quantitative methods, including Rasch analyses, were applied to more than 300 Swiss secondary school students. The final test's conformity to the Rasch model was confirmed with a sample of = 141 students. We further ascertained the bMCU test's applicability as a change measure. Additionally, the criterion validity of the bMCU test was investigated in a sample of secondary school students ( = 66) and a sample of mechanical engineering students ( = 21). In both samples, the bMCU test was a useful predictor of actual student performance.
The bMCU test proved to enable fair, efficient, and simultaneously rigorous measurement of secondary school students' conceptual understanding of Newton's mechanics. This new instrument might fruitfully be used in both physics classrooms and educational research.
对牛顿力学理解的有效评估对于物理课堂和研究都高度相关。已经开发了几种测试。然而,仍然缺少一种有效且公平的概念理解测试,该测试要适合于教授给中学生的内容,并且可以有效地用作前测和后测以反映变化。在本文中,我们描述了基本力学概念理解测试(bMCU)的开发和评估,其设计目的是满足这些要求。
在测试开发过程中,定性和定量方法,包括拉施分析,被应用于300多名瑞士中学生。用141名学生的样本证实了最终测试符合拉施模型。我们进一步确定了bMCU测试作为变化度量的适用性。此外,在中学生样本(n = 66)和机械工程专业学生样本(n = 21)中研究了bMCU测试的效标效度。在两个样本中,bMCU测试都是学生实际表现的有用预测指标。
bMCU测试被证明能够公平、高效且同时严格地测量中学生对牛顿力学的概念理解。这种新工具可能在物理课堂和教育研究中都有成效地使用。