Denman Deborah, Kim Jae-Hyun, Munro Natalie, Speyer Renée, Cordier Reinie
Faculty of Health Sciences, Curtin University, Perth, Australia.
Department of Linguistics, Macquarie University, Sydney, Australia.
Int J Speech Lang Pathol. 2019 Dec;21(6):602-612. doi: 10.1080/17549507.2018.1552716. Epub 2019 Jan 11.
Given the barriers that inconsistent terminology poses for the Speech-Language Pathology (SLP) profession, this study aimed to develop an agreed-upon taxonomy with well-defined categories for describing language assessment practices for children. A taxonomy with illustrative terms for describing assessments across four aspects (modality/domain, purpose, delivery and form) was developed with reference to contemporary literature. In a three round Delphi study, SLPs with expertise in child language were asked to indicate their level of agreement with the taxonomy and provide feedback. Participants were also asked to apply the taxonomy by categorising assessments presented in case studies. A total of 55 participants completed round one, while 43 and 32 completed rounds two and three respectively. Agreed consensus with the taxonomy was achieved in both rounds one and two, with at least 88% of participants agreeing with each aspect and 100% agreeing with the overall structure. In round three, an agreement was reached on 7/10 components for one case study and 4/10 for the other. The development of this taxonomy represents a significant step towards providing detailed terminology for describing language assessments. Future research is needed to investigate implementation strategies to facilitate consistent application of the taxonomy by SLPs.
鉴于术语不一致给言语语言病理学(SLP)专业带来的障碍,本研究旨在开发一种商定的分类法,为描述儿童语言评估实践提供明确的类别。参考当代文献,开发了一种分类法,其中包含用于描述四个方面(方式/领域、目的、实施方式和形式)评估的说明性术语。在一项三轮德尔菲研究中,邀请了在儿童语言方面具有专业知识的言语语言病理学家指出他们对该分类法的认同程度并提供反馈。参与者还被要求通过对案例研究中呈现的评估进行分类来应用该分类法。共有55名参与者完成了第一轮,43名和32名分别完成了第二轮和第三轮。在第一轮和第二轮中均达成了对该分类法的共识,至少88%的参与者同意每个方面,100%同意整体结构。在第三轮中,对于一个案例研究,在10个组成部分中有7个达成了一致,对于另一个案例研究则是4个。该分类法的制定是朝着为描述语言评估提供详细术语迈出的重要一步。未来需要开展研究以调查实施策略,以促进言语语言病理学家对该分类法的一致应用。