a Department of Botany , PMAS Arid Agriculture University , Rawalpindi , Pakistan.
b Department of Environmental Sciences , PMAS Arid Agriculture University , Rawalpindi , Pakistan.
Int J Phytoremediation. 2019;21(2):170-179. doi: 10.1080/15226514.2018.1540547. Epub 2019 Jan 18.
In this study, heavy metal phyto-accumulation potential of selected cultivars of two leafy vegetables on irrigation with municipal wastewater and human health risks were investigated. Municipal wastewater chemistry was recorded significantly different from groundwater control and led to the two-fold high enrichment of soil heavy metal contents (Ni, 19.46; Pb, 23.94; Co, 4.68; Cd, 1.4 in mg/kg, respectively). Interactive effects for phyto-accumulation of most heavy metals were also recorded significant at p < 0.001 in four vegetable cultivars. Heatmap revealed higher accumulation of heavy metals (Fe, Zn, Mn, Cu, Pb, Cr, Co) in spinach cultivars than lettuce cultivars creating elevated health risk index (HRI) and hazard index (HI) values for adults and children. Highest HI was recorded for Lahori palak (adults, 1.42; children, 2.58) and lowest for iceberg (adults, 0.04; children, 0.07). The NPK supplementation improved mineral composition of leafy vegetables within safer human health limits in control treatments. However, in municipal wastewater treatments, NPK fertilization decreased heavy metal uptake and phyto-accumulation in S2 (Lahori palak) than remaining vegetable cultivars leading to reduced health risk values. Because of higher heavy metal phyto-accumulation and health risks, cultivation of spinach cultivars must be discouraged in agro-ecologies receiving municipal wastes, whereas lettuce cultivars should be promoted.
本研究调查了灌溉城市污水对两种叶菜类蔬菜品种重金属植物累积潜力及人体健康风险的影响。城市污水化学性质与地下水对照有显著差异,导致土壤重金属含量(镍、19.46;铅、23.94;钴、4.68;镉、1.4 毫克/千克)增加了一倍。在四种蔬菜品种中,还记录到大多数重金属的植物累积存在显著的相互作用效应(p<0.001)。热图显示,与生菜品种相比,菠菜品种积累了更多的重金属(铁、锌、锰、铜、铅、铬、钴),从而导致成人和儿童的健康风险指数(HRI)和危害指数(HI)值升高。Lahori palak(成人,1.42;儿童,2.58)的 HI 最高,而冰菜(成人,0.04;儿童,0.07)的 HI 最低。在对照处理中,NPK 补充提高了叶菜类蔬菜的矿物质组成,处于更安全的人类健康范围。然而,在城市污水处理中,与其余蔬菜品种相比,NPK 施肥减少了 S2(Lahori palak)对重金属的吸收和植物累积,从而降低了健康风险值。由于重金属的植物累积和健康风险较高,在接收城市废物的农业生态系统中,必须减少菠菜品种的种植,而应推广生菜品种。