Li Shaoliang, Li Xu, Lu Yi
Beijing Ji Shui Tan Hospital, No 31. Xinjiekoudongjie, Xicheng District, Beijing, 100035, China.
Eur J Orthop Surg Traumatol. 2019 May;29(4):775-784. doi: 10.1007/s00590-019-02385-8. Epub 2019 Jan 23.
To describe the morphological characteristics of radial head and coronoid fractures and evaluate the relationship of two fracture patterns in terrible triad.
Distributions of all types of radial head and coronoid fractures according to the Mason, Regan-Morrey, and O'Driscoll classifications were firstly described by reviewing radiographs and computed tomography scans in 92 consecutive terrible triads. Then, distributions of all combinations of radial head and coronoid fractures were reported. Correlation analysis between severity of radial head and coronoid fractures was finally performed.
In radial head fractures, Mason 2 accounted for 68%, Mason 3 accounted for 32%, and no Mason 1 was found. In coronoid fractures, there were 29 type 1, 44 type 2, and 19 type 3 in Regan-Morrey classification and 72 type 1, one type 2, and 19 type 3 in O'Driscoll classification. There were 28 M2R2, 23 M2R1, 16 M3R2, 12 M2R3, seven M3R3, and six M3R1 in combined Mason and Regan-Morrey type. There were 53 M2O1, 19 M3O1, 10 M3O3, nine M2O3, and one M2O2 in combined Mason and O'Driscoll type. A weak correlation was found between radial head and coronoid fractures.
In terrible triad injuries, the most common type of radial head fracture is Mason 2, while the most common type of coronoid fracture is Regan-Morrey type 2 or O'Driscoll type 1. In combinations of two fracture patterns, M2R2 or M2O1 is the most common. Severity of radial head fractures is weakly correlated with coronoid fractures.
描述桡骨头和冠突骨折的形态学特征,并评估“可怕三联征”中两种骨折类型之间的关系。
通过回顾92例连续的“可怕三联征”患者的X线片和计算机断层扫描,首先描述根据梅森(Mason)、雷根-莫里(Regan-Morrey)和奥德里斯科尔(O'Driscoll)分类法的所有类型桡骨头和冠突骨折的分布情况。然后,报告桡骨头和冠突骨折所有组合的分布情况。最后对桡骨头和冠突骨折的严重程度进行相关性分析。
在桡骨头骨折中,梅森2型占68%,梅森3型占32%,未发现梅森1型。在冠突骨折中,根据雷根-莫里分类法有29例1型、44例2型和19例3型,根据奥德里斯科尔分类法有72例1型、1例2型和19例3型。梅森和雷根-莫里联合分型中有28例M2R2、23例M2R1、16例M3R2、12例M2R3、7例M3R3和6例M3R1。梅森和奥德里斯科尔联合分型中有53例M2O1、19例M3O1、10例M3O3、9例M2O3和1例M2O2。桡骨头和冠突骨折之间存在弱相关性。
在“可怕三联征”损伤中,最常见的桡骨头骨折类型是梅森2型,而最常见的冠突骨折类型是雷根-莫里2型或奥德里斯科尔1型。在两种骨折类型的组合中,M2R2或M2O1最为常见。桡骨头骨折的严重程度与冠突骨折呈弱相关。